Friday, November 13, 2026

Ancient Humans did not get Replaced by Africans

New video on Why The 'Out-of-Africa' Theory Is Finally Collapsing:
The Out-of-Africa theory is undergoing a major revision as new fossil evidence challenges our understanding of early human migration.

Recent findings, including the analysis of the Nesher Ramla jaw, suggest that the history of our ancestors is more complex than previously thought. Instead of a simple replacement model, the data points toward significant interbreeding with Neanderthals as populations expanded across the globe.

We synthesize the latest scientific diagrams to examine how these groups interacted during critical periods of human evolution. By looking at the timeline of these movements, we can better appreciate how distinct populations emerged and contributed to the genetic makeup of modern humans.

I do not think that the Out of Africa folks admit that they were wrong.

Update: An AI LLM fact checker says:

This says replacement theory is "collapsing," which is stronger than most paleoanthropologists would say about Nesher Ramla, so expect pushback or a community note.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The Nvidia Scandal

Nvidia CEO and billionaire Jenson Huang was apparently tricked by a China spy agency honeypot scam. He has apologized.

His wife of 40 years had hit the jackpot. She married a man who became of the richest, most influential, and most respected men in the world. By any standards of who is a good catch, he would be in the top 0.001%.

Now he faces adversity, and feminists are telling her to take the money and run. She can file for divorce, and cash in for many billions.

What will she do? Does marriage mean something to her, or is she a gold digger? We shall soon see.

Monday, November 09, 2026

How Dario's Buddies will Control the World

Anthropic wants to go public and take over the work, but the investors will not control the company. A cabal of insiders has schemed to retain control:
Cats are said to have nine lives. Anthropic’s founders, based on their IPO filing, have prepared for one more. The company’s S-1 runs to more than 400 pages; its risk factors alone needed 94 pages, longer than Apple’s entire 1980 IPO prospectus and roughly twice Microsoft’s in 1986. Is this radical transparency, or defensive verbosity?

Anthropic has its reasons. Its prospectus must contemplate the usual corporate misfortunes: competition, regulation, lawsuits, cyberattacks, attrition—plus the distinct possibility that Claude becomes powerful enough to cause catastrophic harm.

Commentators and prospective investors analysing its revenue projections, compute commitments, or critical of trillion-dollar valuations have plenty of fodder here. I have already had my share of Diet Cokagne and completed a tour of the Infinity Room. So I was going to pass, until I came across ten names no one can see.

Succession planning by itself is commonplace in any business. Boards of publicly listed companies take this seriously: for every key position, they agree on a vetted list of two or three credible names. Who could step in tomorrow? Who might be ready in three years? Where are the gaps?

Anthropic’s version is rather more elaborate. Each of its seven co-founders will maintain a confidential, ranked list of up to ten people who may eventually inherit that founder’s membership and voting role inside a special Founder LLC. Five of the other six co-founders must approve the list. The first eight candidates on the list must clear detailed eligibility requirements. Numbers nine and ten do not, although the other founders must still approve them. I particularly like #9 and #10; they remind me of the break glass in emergency signs.

The elaborate planning protocol begins to make sense when we understand what is being passed on. The people on these lists are not prospective CEOs. They inherit something stranger: a founder’s seat in the mechanism that controls the company’s direction. And that changes the succession question entirely.

Succession planning is meant to answer the question: who can do the job next?

Anthropic is asking a different question: who can inherit the founders’ judgment about what to build, protect, and refuse?

That is why its governance plan looks so strange. The company will remain a Public Benefit Corporation. The founders’ special share preserves 50.1% voting power on general shareholder matters. Public investors are being asked to provide oodles of capital to an entity designed so that capital does not have the final word.

Sunday, November 08, 2026

The Reason for College Degrees

Tweet:
Nobody ever talks about this, but the reason you have to go to college is A, because Griggs v. Duke Power Company made it illegal for presumptive employers to IQ test, and B, inner city High-Schools basically aren't allowed to fail a student as long as they physically show up.

So you end up in this trap where a High-School diploma that you worked very hard for means nothing, because a kid who did coloring books and addition and subtraction got a paper saying he has the same qualification. Ok, then just give me an intelligence test, oh wait you cant, thats also illegal because it causes "disparate impact". So now the only proxy for basically literacy and ~105~ IQ is a 4 year meaningless degree that costs 10s of thousands of dollars.

But wait, now they hand those out to anyone, (1/4 of 4yr grads have an IQ of or below 95), so now you need a Master's, or specialty training, or a million other bullshit things. So you get them, but wait, a diploma mill in Hyderabad cranked out 100M guys who also have a Master's on paper, and will work for 1/3 the price, so now you dont have a job. Ok, ill work construction, but wait, you dont live in a State with strong Unions, so any non-specialized construction work is done by slaves from Guatemala, so you decide to stay home and take Percocet instead.

Awesome system we've built.

Saturday, November 07, 2026

2026 Election Lessons

Here is what I learned from the USA election.

Democrat Party efforts for demographic change have paid off. They have a coalition of parasites who can be convinced that they are oppressed.

There is a lot of populist sentiment against tech companies, AI, and data centers.

Zionism has been neutered by the anti-West, anti-colonialist, leftist, and pro-Islam forces.

The public has finally gotten tired of Pres. Trump's antics.

Ron DeSantis is the most likely 2028 Republican nominee. The Democrat field is wide open. The Democrats are likely to win in 2028, unless they make serious mistakes.

Friday, November 06, 2026

English Celebrity is going to Prison

Russell Brand was just convicted:
The comedian and actor has been found guilty of sexually assaulting a woman at a bar in London in 2004.

They’d been at a birthday party in Soho and had been chatting at the bar for less than a minute when Brand grabbed her breasts.

He has been found guilty of sexually assaulting a woman at the Choice FM studios in London in either 2004 or 2005. He grabbed her face and kissed her before touching her breasts and bottom.

Brand has also been found guilty of raping a woman at his then home in London in 2009, days after meeting her at the Hammersmith Apollo theatre where he’d been performing a comedy show.

She visited his home in Hampstead where they had consensual sex before he anally raped her. She had told the court “he hurt me and harmed me and when I asked him to stop he didn’t”.

Brand has also been found guilty of a sexual assault charge while working on a Channel 4 project in 2009.

The 51-year-old laid his head into the groin area of a woman working with him at the time without her consent.

The woman said his mouth and nose were in her vaginal area. She told the court she was repulsed at the situation and reported the incident to her line manager at the time.

I did not follow this case. It is hard to how evidence could prove him guilty beyond reasonable doubt.

Update: Brand was sentenced to 10.5 years in prison. It appears that he was targeted for political reasons. The allegations against him were weak and stale.

Update: Matt Walsh reviews the evidence. For example, one accusation of sexual assault was claimed to have happened in a public bar, but no one else at the bar corroborates the story.

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Convince Democrat Voters to hate White Oppressors

Gene Wu, a Texas Democrat, explains that Democrats can win by convincing gays, Blacks, Asians, Latinos, and non-Christians that they are all oppressed. Even if they do not have much in common with each other, they can all be convinced that Republicans are the enemy.

The tweet says he is the Texas House majority leader, but I think it means minority leader.

Yes, that describes today's Democrat identity politics.

Update: Someone said he really is going to be the majority leader.

Wednesday, November 04, 2026

Trump Reversed Immigration

Source.
Donald Trump has made fearful, even unforgivable mistakes, but he has done something no other president has done in nearly 100 years: He has reversed the relentless increase in the number of foreigners living in the United States. During Mr. Obama’s two terms, the brown and blue lines, the number was up 6.3 million.

In his first term, the first green line, even Mr. Trump let in 1.6 million, and Joe Biden, the purple line, broke all records and in just four years, waved in 8.3 million. This term, Mr. Trump reversed course. By July this year, the number of foreigners was down 2.9 million.

There hasn’t been a drop in the number of foreigners since the Great Depression (except for a tiny dip during Covid). Reversing such a sustained trend is heroic. How did Mr. Trump do it?

Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Today's Election is being Stolen

Today is Election Day in the USA. The NY Times is predicting a landslide win for the Democrat Party. It also says that there has been a record turnout of early and mail-in votes for Democrats.

The trouble with the early votes is that they can be manipulated. The votes are not witness, and there are not independent observers to insure that the votes are cast and collected properly. A Democrat party operative could go to a nursing home, help all the senior to vote, and all the votes end up magically for Democrats.

We used to conduct our elections on Election Day, and nearly all other countries have one-day voting and counting.

California can take a month to count its votes, so it is impossible for observers to verify the count.

Monday, November 02, 2026

The Democrats go Anti-White

I am waiting to see if Michigan elects Abdul El-Sayed. His campaign is almost entirely based on being anti-White, anti-Christian, anti-American, and promising free goodies for parasites. See this 2019 speech are this recent one.

He said, during a Michigan gubernatorial forum in May 2018:

"You may not hate Muslims. But I'll tell you, Muslims definitely hate you."
That's right. Americans are very tolerant of Moslems. But Moslems hate non-Moslems, and will do everything to undermine America.

Here is today's tweet:

Tomorrow, November 3rd, is your last chance to vote to get money out of politics, put money in pockets, and pass Medicare for All.

Get out there (and bring a friend!)

No, this is dishonest. Medicare is a lousy system. I pay far more into it than I get out of it. I want it abolished, not expanded. His campaign is mostly financed by rich out-of-state donors. He is just promising free money for the welfare class.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Krugman wants to Nationalize Satellites

Economist and leftist Trump-hater Paul Krugman writes:
Some may object as follows: Musk owns Starlink. Doesn’t he have the right to do what he wants with a business he owns?

No.

Yes, America has a market economy. And to make this economy work, we need to respect property rights. But we are, first and foremost, a democracy. And in a democracy, the rights of private property don’t and never have included the right to act against the nation’s interest — where democratically elected representatives of the people, not business owners, should decide what is in the nation’s interest. Capitalism is not an excuse for treason. ...

Which reinforces the point that control of Starlink must, one way or another, be taken away from Elon Musk. It’s a matter of national security: we cannot let private individuals make foreign and defense policy, and it would be totally irresponsible to leave a crucial military asset in the hands of a racist, authoritarian conspiracy theorist.

No, we are not "first and foremost, a democracy." The USA founders hated democracy.

What "nation's interest" is he talking about? Not the USA. The USA Pentagon directly controls the military satellites and military Starlink functions.

No, he is talking about Ukraine's interest. He thinks Musk should be doing more to help Ukraine kill Russians in Russia.

Some people are going to vote against the Republicans next week as an anti-war vote. Before you do, consider that Democrats like Krugman are more pro-war than the Republicans. Hakeem Jeffries is likely to be the next Speaker of the House, and he is very pro-Israel and pro-Ukraine.

Friday, October 30, 2026

RIP Patrick Stewart

The actor who played Star Trek captain Picard just died. He was known for his peculiar leadership style, and for being partially assimilated into the Borg:
The Borg are a fictional cybernetic species in the Star Trek franchise, consisting of a vast collective of assimilated individuals linked in a hive mind that relentlessly seeks to incorporate the biological and technological distinctiveness of other species into its own to achieve perfection.1 Operating as a unified entity without individual free will, the Borg function like a single organism, with drones exhibiting a uniform, emotionless demeanor and enhanced capabilities through cybernetic implants that replace organic parts, such as laser-emitting eyes or mechanical appendages.1 Their assimilation process involves injecting nanoprobes into victims to forcibly integrate them into the Collective, often accompanied by the ominous declarations "Resistance is futile" and "You will be assimilated."1
The Borg seemed like a metaphor for the Left. Leftists today are always seeking to absorb everyone into their hive mind. Then they lose free will and go along with the collective. They view it as inevitable that everyone will eventually be absorbed.

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Offense Rates Differ by Nationality

From The Economist magazine. With a log scale so that it does not look so bad.

We would presumably see sharper breakdowns if ethnic groups were divided. "Americas and Caribbean" covers many groups.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

California Reconsidering SAT for College Admissions

The Univ. of California is not allowed to discriminate based on race, so it abolished standardized admission tests. The NY Post reports:
Joel Hass, a mathematics professor at UC Davis, said the results were unsurprising and reflected a growing divide between students who arrive academically prepared and those who struggle with foundational material.

“There is a wider range of interest and preparedness,” Hass said. “We still have a good number of highly qualified students, but also many who are unprepared for college. The preparedness gap between these groups is large.”

Hass said some university instructors were being encouraged to offer remedial courses covering material students should have learned years earlier.

Just 49.3% of California students met or exceeded state English language arts standards in 2025-26, while only 38.4% achieved proficiency in math, according to results released by the state.

Although both figures improved slightly from the previous school year, they remained below pre-pandemic levels. In 2018-19, 50.9% of students met English language arts standards and 39.7% were proficient in math.

The state spent about $134 billion on K-12 schools from all sources in 2025-26, or roughly $26,450 per student, according to the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office.

“The failure of high schools, and more generally K-12 education in California, is a scandal. The state now sends students who might thrive by first going to the community colleges to UC campuses where they are unprepared for a serious academic environment,” Hass told the Post. ...

Hass also pushed back against arguments that the SAT and ACT create barriers for disadvantaged students, saying the exams can help identify talented applicants whose abilities might otherwise be overlooked. 53

What do you think? Post a comment.

“SAT and ACT tests can open doors for talented students who have suffered from poor instruction in poor quality schools,” Hass said.

Rather than placing students in university courses before they are ready, he suggested that some could benefit from strengthening their academic foundations at community colleges before transferring to a UC campus.

The SAT used to be a decent IQ tests. Changes made it less of an IQ test, but it still predicts college success better than other measures.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Democrats Now Controlled by Red/Green Alliance

Tweet:
It is a matter of historical fact that the two groups most prone to murdering or enslaving Christians are Communism and Islam.

The Democrat Party is now under the control of a marriage of convenience between literal Communists and Islamic Jihadists. This unholy alliance is popularly referred to as the "Red/Green Alliance."

If you are an American Christian, know this: the Red/Green Alliance wants you dead, or enslaved, or bankrupted, or persecuted so badly that you will not be allowed to live freely in American society.

They hide behind the lies of benevolence of seemingly harmless masks like Talarico.

Those masks will fall as soon as they achieve power.

There should not be a single adult Christian staying home for the midterms. Christians must vote like their life depends on it, because it does.

Monday, October 26, 2026

John Oliver goes on Nazi Name-calling Rant

I made the mistake of watching half of John Oliver's latest episode. He is hard to listen to because his accent makes him sound retarded, and because he has canned laughter to go with his frequent obscenities.

This one was about Republicans becoming anti-Jewish. As evidence, he said one Republican once posted a picture of his grandfather in a WWII Nazi soldier uniform. As another example, he said Tucker Carlson interviewed Nick Fuentes. But Carlson and Fuentes are not even Republicans, as they are urging votes for Democrats in the current election.

Meanwhile the Democrat Party is being taken over by anti-Israel leftists. A number of prominent Democrats now favor replacing Israel with a Palestinian Arab state. This is an anti-Jewish as you will hear from any American politician. Most Republicans are pro-Israel.

Of course it is an American political tradition to call your enemies Nazis. So I guess I can excuse Oliver calling people Nazis. But much of his argument is based on Republicans calling other Republicans Nazis.

Nazis were National Socialists, and it is today's Democrats who are embracing Socialism.

In the Gaza War, each side says the other side is like the Nazis. Such language is not helpful.

Male Female Relationships are Broken

I found this comment online:
Riddle me this. It's clear what is expected of men by women. Provision, protection, be the traditional man, be 6ft tall, make 200K/yr, etc...but a woman’s responsibilities are framed less as obligations to a man and more as obligations to herself: to know her worth, maintain her standards, establish boundaries, preserve her independence, prioritize her emotional well-being, and avoid settling for a relationship that doesn’t meet her needs.

She is encouraged to expect initiative, generosity, emotional availability, financial stability, respect, and consistent effort from a prospective man, **while retaining the freedom to decide how much she wishes to contribute financially, domestically, and emotionally**. Traditional expectations of femininity, such as nurturing, homemaking, accommodating a partner, and prioritizing his needs, are increasingly treated as personal choices rather than duties. The resulting cultural message, particularly visible in dating advice and social media, often defines a good man by what he provides to a woman, while defining a good woman by how well she advocates for herself. The contract has been broken and until this dynamic changes to a healthy, reciprocal exchange between men and women, we will continue to drift.

There is some truth to this.

This new video argues that this broken system explains the declining fertility in industrialized countries:

The Birthrate Collapse is a Prisoner's Dilemma

Everyone has a theory about why people stopped having kids. The economy. Housing. Phones. Feminism. Men. Governments have bet hundreds of billions on those theories and lost every time.

This is a different explanation. It doesn't start with money, it doesn't need a villain, and once you see it you'll see it in every couple you know, including the one you're in.

The uncomfortable part isn't the cause. It's what it means if nothing can fix it.

In particular, fertility cannot be raised by lowering housing costs or giving monetary incentives. It says men and women are happiest and most productive in a stable long-term marriage with kids, and millions of couples achieve that. However the risks to both men and women are such that it is rational for them to stay single.

The basic problem is that female is to mate with the highest-status male. Cinderella wants to marry the Prince, even though she is a poor peasant.

Traditionally, girls were constrained by the available boys. A girl would go with a good choice, and social pressures would keep them together.

Now an average woman in her 20s can go on short-term dates with high-value men. For a couple of weeks, she can have the excitement of landing a prince -- handsome, rich, athletic, tall, or whatever else she desires. A woman with unconstrained sexuality quickly gets wildly unrealistic expectations. The mid-level guy in her social class is no longer good enough for her.

That is the theory, anyway.

Update: Here is an economic argument: How Korean Feminism Finally Made It Impossible to Make Babies.

Saturday, October 24, 2026

New Videos Explain Recent Human Evolution

I post a lot about human nature, and three videos on the subject dropped this week.

Why White People Are So WEIRD

Most of the world doesn’t think like us. So how did we become so WEIRD?

Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich and Democratic societies are psychological outliers. From our individualism to our willingness to trust strangers, many things we assume are ordinary human nature are unusual by global and historical standards.

Joseph Henrich’s The WEIRDest People in the World offers a surprising explanation: the medieval Church’s campaign against cousin marriage weakened Europe’s clans and helped transform the Western mind. I explore his argument, the research behind it, and what it might explain about the civilisation we inherited.

Why Are We the Only Human Species Left?
We are the only human species left on Earth.

Once, we shared our planet with other human species, including Neanderthals and Denisovans. Today, they're gone, leaving behind fossils, ancient tools and traces of their DNA within our own. So how did Homo sapiens end up as the last humans standing?

For decades, we believed our ancestors survived because they were smarter, stronger or better adapted. But what if the real secret to our success was something far more unexpected? What if we survived because we were friendlier?

Some researchers believe our ability to cooperate, build relationships and form larger social networks may have given us a crucial evolutionary edge, an advantage of just 2 per cent that, over thousands of years, could have changed the course of human history

Why Europeans and Asians Evolved So Differently
Two strangers sit across from each other on a flight. One has pale skin and light eyes. The other has straight black hair and a fold at the corner of each eye. Their ancestors were probably neighbors 50,000 years ago. So why do Europeans and East Asians look so different today? In this video, we follow the ancient DNA to find out. You'll learn how evolution solved the same skin-lightening problem twice with completely different mutations, why Cheddar Man had dark skin and blue eyes, how Neanderthals and Denisovans left their mark, and why the ability to drink milk spread so recently.

We also cover the EDAR gene behind thicker hair, the single-letter change that decides your earwax type, the Tibetan altitude gene borrowed from an extinct species, and what science still can't explain, like the epicanthic fold.

And we cover the most important part: why these visible differences are real but tiny, and why human variation is a gradient, not a set of boxes.

These are all about genetic influences over humans. The first over the last millennium, the second over the last 100,000 years, and the third over 10,000 years.

Forty years ago, evolutionists claim that humans had not evolved in the last 100k years. There is overwhelming evidence that humans have evolved, evolved even in the last millennium, and that the evolved differences are crucial for understanding the world today.

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Modern Morality Consists of Blaming Whites

Popular blogger and computer science professor Scott Aaronson usually comments on AI and quantum computers, but now urges a vote in the next election. I am trying to understand his point of view. He feels strongly about two issues:

1. He is militantly pro-Israel. He aggressively defends Israel's military actions, and considers them essential for its survival and for Jews like himself.

2. He has Trump Derangement Syndrome. He hates Pres. Trump, and everything about him.

In addition, he sometimes gets into fights with the Woke Left. He protests that he agrees with 99% of the Left, but very much opposes today's Left.

This all baffles me. Trump is possibly the most pro-Israel President we have ever had. The Democrat Party is being taken over by Socialists who want to liquidate Israel. Trump also actively opposes the Woke Left policies that Aaronson also opposes. Aaronson should be happy with Trump.

Here is Aaronson's endorsement of Democrat James Talarico in Texas:

So then, this is my candidate: the guy who’s strategically silent on the wildly-popular streamer who’d gladly see my Israeli family members raped and beheaded, rather than campaigning with that streamer like Abdul El-Sayed did in Michigan. I unironically believe that, for Talarico, it took genuine moral courage to resist the whole momentum of his party’s youth even to this extent.
What? That sounds like a reason to vote Republican.

Jews vote about 80% for Democrats, and raise most of the party's funds. It is baffling to me that Jews would stick to Democrats, while the party gets taken over by Leftists who want to exterminate the Jews.

Here is how Aaronson replies to the Democrat Party being an anti-White party:

All the same, in the United States in 2026 — which is still a majority-white country, run by majority-white politicians like James Talarico — I view us as still a billion miles away from the point of (say) shackling whites into ships to be enslaved forever, or herding white children into gas chambers, or any of the other world-historic injustices whose repudiation is a large part of what modern morality consists of. If I ever see that change, I’ll say so.
Wow. He is essentially saying that Whites are privileged, and modern morality consists of blaming Whites for slavery and genocide.

This is absurd, but there is a disgusting truth to it. Our schools today spend most of American History talking about how terrible slavery was.

Here in the modern US, though, those who obsess about anti-white racism are frankly not the standard-bearers of Western civilization who impress me or who I want. (Richard Hanania, himself a recovering former obsessive on the topic, has written about this much more eloquently than I could.)
Hanania is of Christian Palestinian descent, and trashes European Americans on a daily basis. Lately he has been posting about how Indian-Americans are superior, and how the USA should import more Indians to replace White Americans. So when Aaronson says that Hanania has eloquently trashed White Americans, that is what he means.

White Christian Americans have nothing to apologize for. They have done much more for the world than any other group. It is not even close.

The Democrat Party of today is defined by identity politics against White Christian Americans, and blaming them for everything. They brag that soon they will be able to import enough non-whites that they will be able to subjugate the Whites, and extract wealth.

Update: Peter Woit agrees with Aaronson to urge everyone to vote Democrat, but for different reasons. Woit wants to destroy Israel. He also agrees to block comments, because Trump supporters are too horrible to be allowed a voice.

Update: In case you doubt that Hanania is anti-white, he just posted:

Asian and Hispanic turnout is surging in Texas.

The best case scenario for the election is non-whites punishing Republicans for the last few years.

He often posts how he hopes non-whites win elections.

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

What is a First-Generation Immigrant?

Gemini 3.8 Flash objects to some of my terminology. It says:

Your confusion is entirely justified. The terminology around immigrant generations is notoriously ambiguous and has been debated by demographers, sociologists, and everyday speakers for decades.

Which Definition is Standard and More Common?

In official statistics, sociology, and standard contemporary English, the convention is the opposite of your intuitive zero-indexing model:

  • First-generation immigrant: Refers to the person who actually immigrated (foreign-born, relocated as an adult or adolescent).
  • Second-generation: Refers to the children born in the destination country to at least one foreign-born parent.
  • Third-generation (and higher): Refers to grandchildren of immigrants whose parents were already native-born.

This convention is explicitly followed by the U.S. Census Bureau, the Pew Research Center, the United Nations, and academic sociological literature. Under this standard framework, "generation" refers to the chronological wave of the family's presence in the country, where Generation 1 is the pioneer cohort that stepped off the boat or plane.

The Alternative (Your) Interpretation

Your interpretation—that the foreign-born person is "generation zero" and the first person generated or born on domestic soil is "first generation"—is neither uncommon nor baseless.

In fact, some older texts, community groups, and everyday speakers (particularly in countries like Canada or among certain diaspora communities in the United States) have historically used "first-generation" to mean "the first generation born as citizens in the new land." Because of this genuine linguistic split, scholars often use unambiguous phrases such as "foreign-born" and "native-born of foreign parentage" when precision is critical.

Sociologists also introduced fractional classifications to address edge cases, most notably the "1.5 generation", which describes children who immigrated alongside their parents before adulthood. Because they were born abroad but socialized and educated in the destination country, they share traits of both the first and second cohorts.

Is It Accurate to Call a Native-Born Citizen a "Second-Generation Immigrant"?

Strictly speaking from a legal and semantic standpoint, calling someone born in the United States an "immigrant" is contradictory. Under U.S. law, anyone born on domestic soil is a birthright citizen and never underwent immigration. Therefore, they are not an immigrant; they are an American citizen by birth.

For this reason, demographic institutions typically avoid pairing "generation" with "immigrant" for the native-born. Instead, they prefer:

  • "Second-generation American"
  • "Children of immigrants"
  • "Second generation" (used as a standalone noun)

When popular culture or media outlets use the shorthand "second-generation immigrant," they are treating "immigrant" as a cultural or sociological descriptor rather than a legal one. In that context, it denotes someone raised inside the immigrant experience, navigating bicultural households, heritage languages, and the distinct assimilation challenges of an immigrant family.

Does "Immigrant" Include the Broader Family?

In everyday parlance, people frequently speak of an "immigrant family" as a collective unit. That label naturally encompasses the household as a whole, even when some siblings or children were born locally.

However, applying the label "an immigrant" directly to an individual who was born in the country is factually inaccurate. If their parents were the ones who moved, they are a child of immigrants or a second-generation American. If only their grandparents moved, they are of immigrant descent or third generation, but neither they nor their immediate household are considered immigrants.