In the first place, we should insist that if the immigrant who comes here in good faith becomes an American and assimilates himself to us, he shall be treated on an exact equality with everyone else, for it is an outrage to discriminate against any such man because of creed, or birthplace, or origin. But this is predicated upon the person's becoming in every facet an American, and nothing but an American ... There can be no divided allegiance here. Any man who says he is an American, but something else also, isn't an American at all. We have room for but one flag, the American flag ... We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language ... and we have room for but one sole loyalty and that is a loyalty to the American people.He also promoted the idea that our school should only teach in English.
Saturday, April 15, 2006
Teddy Roosevelt on being an American
Theodore Roosevelt's ideas on Immigrants and being an AMERICAN in 1907:
Thursday, April 13, 2006
Banning bukkake
Connecticut news:
Outraged by an incident in a University of Connecticut dormitory, the state Senate voted unanimously Tuesday to change the definition of sexual assault to include cases without direct physical contact. ...Weird. Apparently they want to ban bukkake. I had never heard of it. The next time you hear of someone accused of sexual assault, remember that he might not have touched anyone.
The new law would help restore "the pride, self-worth, and safety of myself and other women victimized by thoughtless individuals such as the three men who sexually violated me and will only be convicted of a misdemeanor at best," she said.
Top ten worst words
The BBC lists the top ten worst words:
1. RetardThe article says that, "Golfer Tiger Woods has been criticised for saying he played like 'a spaz'."
2. Spastic
3. Window-licker
4. Mong
5. Special
6. Brave
7. Cripple
8. Psycho
9. Handicapped
10. Wheelchair-bound
Tuesday, April 11, 2006
Domestic violence and men's rights
Harry Crouch writes, in the San Diego paper:
Phyllis Schlafly's "Weak women and the Bill of Rights" (Opinion, March 30) is right on the money. I was in court again watching the daily herding of men charged with domestic violence. The judge, public defenders and prosecutors all taught the "anti-male and anti-marriage notions" Schlafly describes.You can find her other columns on this subject here.
Monday, April 10, 2006
Duke Lacrosse story
The Duke Lacrosse story is blowing up. All 46 DNA tests came back negative.
There were holes in the stripper-accuser's story from the start. Since she was only accusing 3 players, she should have had to pick them out of a police lineup.
The main piece of evidence is now her broken fake fingernails that were found at the scene. That is not enough for a rape conviction.
I think that the press should have waited for the DNA tests, since the police said that they would be dispositive. Now they have branded all the boys as being guilty, and the accuser hasn't even been named. At this point, either the charges should be dropped or the accuser should be named. I'll post her name here if I find out.
There were holes in the stripper-accuser's story from the start. Since she was only accusing 3 players, she should have had to pick them out of a police lineup.
The main piece of evidence is now her broken fake fingernails that were found at the scene. That is not enough for a rape conviction.
I think that the press should have waited for the DNA tests, since the police said that they would be dispositive. Now they have branded all the boys as being guilty, and the accuser hasn't even been named. At this point, either the charges should be dropped or the accuser should be named. I'll post her name here if I find out.
NH revising payment guidelines
AP reports:
CONCORD, N.H. (New Hampshire) Attorney General Kelly Ayotte says the state should seek new bids for a child support contract that nearly went to an economist who was jailed in Georgia for failing to make payments to his children.This story is fishy, because no one is ever order to make payments to his children. But more to the point, no one should ever trust a closed-door process of developing guidelines anyway. They should be verifily based on demonstrable data using an accepted methodology.
R-Mark Rogers of Peachtree City, Georgia, had been the low bidder for a contract to retool New Hampshire's child support guidelines. At the time, the governor, health commissioner and a panel examining the bids didn't know Rogers served time in the 1990s over more than 72-hundred dollars in owed child support.
Ayotte says this time around, bidders should be asked to disclose any pertinent legal history so officials can fully evaluate whether potential conflicts or biases exist.
PC children's books
Foxnews reports:
The globalization of the market for children's books has brought Australian authors face-to-face with American standards of political correctness, according to a report in The Age, and the authors are none to happy about it.
Among the things deemed verbotten in illustrations for the books, the authors say, are udders on cows, large lips on dark-skinned children and so-called "Asian-looking" eyes.
"It's not only gone mad, I think it's completely irrational ... to start to think that portraying a race in a true and honest way is somehow derogatory or demeaning," says illustrator Roland Harvey.
Among the other guidelines handed down by U.S. publishers:
--Avoid stereotypes such as females as peripheral/helpers to active/leading males, or senior citizens as infirm, with canes, doddering.
--Elderly people should be shown as active members of society; unless relevant to text they should not be shown in wheelchairs.
--Show mothers involved in outside employment (not in aprons in kitchens).
--Show African-Americans in positions of power, not just in service industries.
--Show African-Americans and other people of colour with a range of skin tones. Hair texture should vary from straight to curly.
--Do not stereotype Asian people with glasses, bowl-shaped haircuts, or as intellectuals.
--No large groups of people without an appropriate ethnic mix and male/female ratio.
--No "help the disabled" pictures ? show disabled people doing for themselves and others.
--Show many types of family grouping. Take care not to imply that one-parent homes are broken.
Sunday, April 09, 2006
Why vegetarians are wrong
This British guy has theories for why men can't read female minds and why vegetarians should be force fed with lard. Some of his evolutionary psychology theories are testable.
Friday, April 07, 2006
Sunshine helps prevent cancer
Health news:
WOMEN with high exposure to the sun as teenagers may be protected against breast cancer in later life, doctors have found.Millions of Americans avoid sunlight and use excessive amounts of sunscreen because they think that they are reducing their cancer risk.
Boosting levels of vitamin D could be beneficial at a time when breast cells are developing. New evidence of the ability of the "sunshine vitamin" to reduce the risk of cancer comes from two studies presented in the US. ...
"But they don't need to expose their breasts to gain protection, just put on a swimsuit or bikini, because vitamin D is made in the skin."
Thursday, April 06, 2006
Forced gay ed
California news:
Sacramento, Calif. - The California state Senate will consider a bill that would require schools to teach students about the contributions gays and lesbians have made to society - an effort that supporters say is an attempt to battle discrimination and opponents say is designed to use the classroom to get children to embrace homosexuality.If they were really interested in accuracy and diversity, then they would also teach the precise reasons that some people find homosexuality unacceptable.
The bill, which was passed by a Senate committee Tuesday, would require schools to buy textbooks "accurately" portraying "the sexual diversity of our society." More controversially, it could require students hear history lessons on "the contributions of people who are lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender to the economic, political, and social development of California and the United States of America."
Wednesday, April 05, 2006
Sex differences in the brain
Brain news:
Larry Cahill, an associate professor of neurobiology and behavior, and Lisa Kilpatrick, a former postdoctoral fellow in his laboratory, have found that the amygdala, an almond-shaped structure found on both sides of the brain, behaves very differently in males and females while the subjects are at rest. In men, the right amygdala is more active and shows more connections with other regions of the brain, even when there is no outside stimulus. Conversely, in women, the left amygdala is more connected with other regions of the brain. In addition, the regions of the brain with which the amygdala communicates while a subject is at rest are different in men and women.This might explain more than irritable bowels.
The finding could be key to determining why gender-related differences exist in certain psychiatric disorders and how to treat a variety of illnesses.
The study appears in this week's issue of NeuroImage. ...
Cahill believes this study could be the basis for a fuller understanding and treatment of a number of disorders that affect one gender or the other. For example, in the study, one of the brain areas communicating with the amygdala in women is implicated in disorders such as depression and irritable bowel syndrome, which predominantly affect women.
Tuesday, April 04, 2006
Penn and Teller
I happened to see a couple of Penn and Teller TV shows titled "On Bulls***". They seem to be a profanity-laden rants against people or organizations that they don't like. This time, Penn was unhappy about the lessons he learned as a Boy Scout, and now he doesn't like the fact that the Boy Scouts have a policy against homosexuals and atheists. As proof of the foolishness of the Boy Scout policy, he did an experiment to show that gay kids can fold an American flag as well as straights.
Usually the profanity doesn't bother me, but I thought that Penn said the word "a**hole" a few times too many when ranting about homosexuals.
George writes:
Usually the profanity doesn't bother me, but I thought that Penn said the word "a**hole" a few times too many when ranting about homosexuals.
George writes:
Penn wasn't calling the gays a**holes. He was using the epithet for straight guys who didn't want to associate with gays. They were boy scouts who even defended having the phrase "morally straight" in their traditional Scout Oath.Whatever. I can see why the Boy Scouts might not want Penn to be a Scoutmaster.
Donkeys better than wives
India news:
A textbook used at schools in the Indian state of Rajasthan compares housewives to donkeys, and suggests the animals make better companions as they complain less and are more loyal to their "masters", The Times of India reported today.Political correctness will require removing the reference, not correcting it.
"A donkey is like a housewife ... In fact, the donkey is a shade better, for while the housewife may sometimes complain and walk off to her parents' home, you'll never catch the donkey being disloyal to his master," the newspaper reported, quoting a Hindi-language primer meant for 14-year-olds. ...
"The comparison was made in good humour," state education official AR Khan was quoted as saying.
Monday, April 03, 2006
Clarity in the law
Someone recommended this PBS news show for the full story on FCC indecency fines. It had this exchange:
I don't think that the standards for clarity in a criminal case are any higher. Just ask Quattrone, M. Jackson, DeLay, etc. Look at this recent article in the Si Valley paper:
JEFFREY BROWN: Mr. Peters, what do you think? Do you -- do you see a clear line, a clear definition, from what the FCC did, that will help broadcasters and -- and the audience understand what constitutes indecency?Peters was supposed to be defending the FCC,
ROBERT PETERS: Well, I will tell you, I -- I think, admittedly, the line is not crystal clear.
And I suspect, if this were a criminal case, the -- the FCC would have a much harder time justifying what it has done, because, in criminal cases, the standards for clarity have to be higher.
I don't think that the standards for clarity in a criminal case are any higher. Just ask Quattrone, M. Jackson, DeLay, etc. Look at this recent article in the Si Valley paper:
But leaving kids home alone is not necessarily against the law -- no matter how young they are or how long their parents are gone.A lot of criminal laws are deliberately vague. I think that it was the PBS news show that was deliberately vague about why the FCC issued indecency fines.
As a very general rule, children are ready for the latch-key life for short periods when they are 12 or 13, child-care experts say. The law, however, is deliberately vague to give prosecutors the flexibility to decide when a home-alone case becomes a crime.
Sunday, April 02, 2006
Fat patients
This CNN story details hospitals struggling with fat patients:
Last year, patient care director Colleen Becker decided to check the numbers. She looked at a daily hospital census -- about one-third of the 900 patients weighed 350 pounds or more.Wow. I had no idea that so many fat people were clogging up hospitals. (This story is not on the Wikipedia list of April Fools hoaxes, so I guess it is serious.)
Startled, Becker checked another date, then another. The numbers were consistent. On some days, half the patients were obese. Some weighed 500 pounds or more. ...
The hospital is replacing many of its beds -- built to handle people weighing up to 350 pounds -- with beds for 500-pound patients.
"Three-hundred-fifty pounds is nowhere near what we need for beds now," said Art Kidrow, a nurse manager at Barnes-Jewish. "We've had
some 650-pounders up here."
Friday, March 31, 2006
How to cheat on the SAT test
Want an extra edge in the SAT test? More and more students are demanding extra time by claiming some dubious disability. There are psychologists, such as this one, who will give a mail-order diagnosis of some sort of learning disability. The the College Board folks have to give you extra time, or they'd be discriminating against the handicapped. As many as 10% of the test-takers take advantage of these procedures.
ABC News reports:
ABC News reports:
March 30, 2006 ? - When Ali Hellberg, 19, was in prep school, she said several of her classmates obtained notes from psychologists diagnosing them with learning disabilities, even though they didn't have any learning problems.
They faked learning disabilities to get extra time to take the Scholastic Aptitude Test, or SAT, in the hopes of getting a higher score, she said.
"I had a friend who is a good math student but is no math brain, and she got extended time and got a perfect score on her math SAT," Hellberg said.
That friend now attends an Ivy League school. ...
Approximately 300,000 students will take the three-hour-and-forty-five-minute SAT this Saturday; about 30,000 taking the test this year will be given special accommodations, including extra time.
3 claim boob doc D-formed them
NY Post reports:
Three angry women claim an Upper East Side plastic-surgeon-to-the-stars turned them into freaks by stuffing massive, Pamela Anderson-sized breast implants into their chests when they wanted only modest boob jobs. ...They did manage to button their shirts in order to pose for a newspaper picture.
"I wanted to leave with a 34B - but the day after my surgery, I was huge," said Felice Rosenbaum, of Manhattan, who claims her B-cup breasts were inflated to a whopping double-D.
"I was horrified," she said. "I went into my closet and I couldn't button anything.
Thursday, March 30, 2006
Basic Instinct advice
Sharon Stone is not embarrassed to give sex advice to teenagers. She ought to be.
The day we won the Cold War
Richard Reeves wrote:
At the end of 1987, Reagan's seventh year in office, Gorbachev came to Washington. There was a state dinner on Dec. 8, which ended with Gorbachev and his wife standing and belting out the lively "Moscow Nights" as Van Cliburn played the piano. Two days later, the best of the conservative columnists, Reagan's best friend in the press, George Will, wrote, "Dec. 8, 1987, will be remembered as the day the Cold War was lost."
In fact, it was the day we won the Cold War.
Attacks on Barry Bonds
The attacks on Barry Bonds continue. Mike Lupica wrote:
The comparison to Pete Rose is also instructive. Rose and Bonds are two of the greatest players in baseball history. Both were savagely attacked by sportswriters for unproven allegations. I think that both players should be celebrated.
Barry Bonds is Bud Selig's Pete Rose. Selig has to go after Bonds, officially make him a suspect in the eyes of his sport, before another season begins, the way the late A.Bartlett Giamatti went after Rose, who denied and denied and denied his gambling the way Bonds has denied his use of steroids.Now Selig has made Bonds an official suspect, and the media circus continues. Lupica continues:
Here is Bonds on May 21, 2001, ... On the same day, the same newspaper asked him about the possibility of breaking Henry Aaron's record of 755 career home runs someday.Why is it hard to believe that 5 years ago, Bonds didn't think that he would be in the game long enough to break Aaron's record? In that 5 years, Bonds has played far better than anyone expected, and yet it is still doubtful that he will break the record. Some people think that he will retire at the end of the year, and he is unlikely to break the record this year.
"Hell, no," Bonds said in the Chronicle. "I promise you from the bottom of my heart I won't be in the game that long."
You believe nothing he says now.
The comparison to Pete Rose is also instructive. Rose and Bonds are two of the greatest players in baseball history. Both were savagely attacked by sportswriters for unproven allegations. I think that both players should be celebrated.
Tuesday, March 28, 2006
Low-context cultures
I talked to someone who took a grad psychology course in communicating with strangers. Apparently the textbooks say that America and Europe are low-context cultures, where people mean what they say and say what they mean. Other parts of the world are high-context cultures, where people try to communicate things that may be contrary to the plain meaning of their words.
We have a word for when someone says one thing and means another. It is called "irony". But it occurs so rarely in American speech that most people think that the word "irony" means something else.
Americans and Europeans also have different modes of communication. Americans deal in facts, and emphasize empirical realities to justify what they say. Europeans have their minds made up about various ideas, and ignore any facts that might get in the way.
Part of the difference is explained by American individualism.
This communication theory is supposed to explain why American have difficulty understanding the speech and behavior of foreigners -- we don't have the context to make sense of it. I am not sure whether the theory predicts that foreigners can understand Americans or not. I would think that it would be much easier to understand a low-context statement because the words have their plain meaning. But apparently many people in other countries have a lot of trouble with facts and plain language statements, and they just automatically translate everything that they hear into relativized meanings which are subject to their own personal prejudices.
We have a word for when someone says one thing and means another. It is called "irony". But it occurs so rarely in American speech that most people think that the word "irony" means something else.
Americans and Europeans also have different modes of communication. Americans deal in facts, and emphasize empirical realities to justify what they say. Europeans have their minds made up about various ideas, and ignore any facts that might get in the way.
Part of the difference is explained by American individualism.
This communication theory is supposed to explain why American have difficulty understanding the speech and behavior of foreigners -- we don't have the context to make sense of it. I am not sure whether the theory predicts that foreigners can understand Americans or not. I would think that it would be much easier to understand a low-context statement because the words have their plain meaning. But apparently many people in other countries have a lot of trouble with facts and plain language statements, and they just automatically translate everything that they hear into relativized meanings which are subject to their own personal prejudices.
Monday, March 27, 2006
Don't burn the food
Freakonomics blog says:
In a sample of 13 African countries between 1999 and 2004, 52% of women surveyed say they think that wife beating is justified if she neglects the children; around 45% think it's justified if she goes out without telling the husband or argues with him; 36% if she refuses sex, and 30% if she burns the food.American women should count their blessings.
And this is what the women think.
Friday, March 24, 2006
Recanted child abuse testimony
Nashville news:
Sentenced six years ago to 55 years in prison for rape and sexual abuse, Ben Kiper's conviction rested solely on the testimony of his accuser, his 10-year-old stepdaughter.Bill O'Reilly of Fox News is on a big campaign to pass Jessica's Law to mandate very long prison sentences in cases like this. He argues that anyone who disagrees must not care about children. He should have a guest on his program to tell the stories of men serving long sentences based on the flimsiest evidence.
There was no physical evidence, no medical exam and no testimony from any corroborating witnesses at his trial in 2000 in Butler Circuit Court.
So when the girl, now 16, recanted her allegations last October -- swearing under oath that her stepmother forced her to falsely accuse Kiper during a custody dispute -- you might have expected the 35-year-old inmate to go free, or at least win a new trial.
"It is simply intolerable if a state allows an innocent person to remain incarcerated on the basis of lies," one of his attorneys wrote a month later.
But five months after the recantation, Kiper remains at the Green River Correctional Complex in Central City. And he may well stay there, because courts have traditionally viewed such testimony with great suspicion. Some have said no form of evidence is more unreliable.
The thinking is that witnesses can be too easily coerced into changing their testimony. Plus, when witnesses change their story, it inherently calls their credibility into question.
Wednesday, March 22, 2006
Fuzzy thinking in dope-heads
The journal Neurology reports:
Neuropsychological deficits in long-term frequent cannabis usersThe sample is small, but this just confirms that marijuana stays in the system for over 24 hours.
The authors examined neuropsychological functioning in 20 long-term (LT), 20 shorter term (ST) heavy frequent cannabis users, and 24 controls after abstinence for ?24 hours prior to testing. LT users performed significantly worse on verbal memory and psychomotor speed. LT and ST users had a higher proportion of deficits on verbal fluency, verbal memory, attention, and psychomotor speed. Specific cognitive domains appear to deteriorate with increasing years of heavy frequent cannabis use.
Monday, March 20, 2006
Using 911 tapes
Did you know that you can call 911, make a criminal accusation against someone, and send the man to jail? He can be prosecuted based on those 911 tapes without you ever having to testify at his trial.
The 6th Amendment to the US Constitution says that a criminal defendant has a right to confront the witnesses against him at trial, and the US Supreme Court is currently considering letting defendants Davis and Hammon exercise that right.
A couple of lawyers in the domestic violence industry argue:
is limiting the ability of feminist do-gooders to bust up marriages.
Sometimes a couple has a fight and then reconciles, but prosecutors
want to jail the husband anyway.
To convict Davis, the court had to justify the use of 911 tapes:
The 6th Amendment to the US Constitution says that a criminal defendant has a right to confront the witnesses against him at trial, and the US Supreme Court is currently considering letting defendants Davis and Hammon exercise that right.
A couple of lawyers in the domestic violence industry argue:
Domestic violence accounts for up to 34 percent of all reported violent crimes, but it is notoriously difficult to prosecute, ... In the 1980's and 1990's, the refusal of victims to cooperate in the prosecution of their batterers may have resulted in the dismissal of as many as 70 percent of all domestic violence cases.In other words, the US Constitution's ban on the use of hearsay evidence
In recent years, however, prosecutors, police officers and advocates for domestic violence victims have developed techniques, together known as "evidence-based prosecution," that focus on the use of reliable evidence, like 911 tapes, to build cases that do not depend on the cooperation of the victim.
is limiting the ability of feminist do-gooders to bust up marriages.
Sometimes a couple has a fight and then reconciles, but prosecutors
want to jail the husband anyway.
To convict Davis, the court had to justify the use of 911 tapes:
The Washington Supreme Court first determined that the purpose of an emergency 911 call "is generally not to 'bear witness'" but rather to obtain "help to be rescued from peril." ... The court rejected the ar gument that McCottry reasonably knew that her call would later be used to prosecute petitioner, finding "no evidence that McCottry had such knowledge or that it influenced her decision to call 911."I think that most people know that 911 tapes can be used on court. If not, you'd better learn now.
Saturday, March 18, 2006
Decline of patriarchy and birthrates
Phillip Longman writes:
Another article describes women who have given up dating, and just look for sperm donors. Some of these women have dated 100s of men looking for Mr. Right, but decided that none of them were good enough to marry. My hunch is that most of them are feminists with bad attitudes.
Patriarchy does not simply mean that men rule. Indeed, it is a particular value system that not only requires men to marry but to marry a woman of proper station. It competes with many other male visions of the good life, and for that reason alone is prone to come in cycles. Yet before it degenerates, it is a cultural regime that serves to keep birthrates high among the affluent, while also maximizing parents' investments in their children. No advanced civilization has yet learned how to endure without it.More here.
Through a process of cultural evolution, societies that adopted this particular social system -- which involves far more than simple male domination -- maximized their population and therefore their power, whereas those that didn't were either overrun or absorbed. This cycle in human history may be obnoxious to the enlightened, but it is set to make a comeback.
Another article describes women who have given up dating, and just look for sperm donors. Some of these women have dated 100s of men looking for Mr. Right, but decided that none of them were good enough to marry. My hunch is that most of them are feminists with bad attitudes.
Paternity registries
NY Times:
Under Florida law, and that of other states, an unmarried father has no right to withhold consent for adoption unless he has registered with the state putative father registry before an adoption petition is filed. ...I never heard about those registries, the article explains that they are ineffective.
Although one in every three American babies has unwed parents, birth fathers' rights remain an unsettled area, ...
While women have the right to get an abortion, or to have and raise a child, without informing the father, courts have increasingly found that when birth mothers choose adoption, fathers who have shown a desire for involvement have rights, too.
But to claim those rights most states require a father to put his name on a registry. While about 30 states now have registries, they vary widely.
Thursday, March 16, 2006
Choice For Men
Cathy Young writes about the Roe v Wade for men lawsuit:
I do think that the case illustrates rather strongly the unfairness to men of the current legal regime. With legal abortion, a woman who gets pregnant can get out of this situation with minimal consequences (unless you believe that an abortion is a profound trauma, which it does not seem to be for most women). For a man in his mid-20s to be ordered to pay $500 a month for the next 18 years -- and presumably more if his income increases -- is no trivial burden. It means a radically altered lifestyle, including seriously reduced opportunities to have a real family if he wants one.She makes a number of sensible points. There are also some contrary comments. We need a public debate on this issue.
Anorexia is not a choice
Medical news:
Researchers studying anorexia in twins conclude that more than half a person's risk for developing the sometimes fatal eating disorder is determined by genes.If that is true, then I guess that I can quit trying to teach good eating habits to my daughter, and go back to making snide remarks about fat kids.
Most experts already believe there is a strong genetic component to the disorder, which mostly affects girls and women. The new study "hammers home the fact that these are biologically based disorders," said Cynthia Bulik, lead author of the study, who is a psychiatrist at the School of Medicine at UNC Chapel Hill.
"We need to stop viewing them as a choice. ... The patients feel guilty, the providers tell them things like they should just eat, parents are blamed, the insurance companies won't fund treatment because they think it's a choice. It's held us back."
Wednesday, March 15, 2006
Bonds deserves to break Aaron's record
The MSM attacks on Barry Bonds are unrelenting. Among the silly suggestions, some sportswriters are arguing that Bonds should retire before breaking Hank Aaron's home run record. They always praise Aaron for breaking Babe Ruth's record in the face of criticism.
Aaron never got 1% of the media criticism that Bonds has received. The press hates Bonds, and has always hated him. I hope Bonds breaks Aaron's record.
Bonds has been a much better baseball player than Aaron was. Barry Bonds won seven MVP awards and finished second in the voting twice; Hank Aaron only narrowly won one MVP.
George writes:
While Bonds is suspected of using steroids, so are a lot of other hitters and pitchers. Somehow Bonds has done better than all those other suspected hitters. Maybe his records are all the more impressive if he got his home runs off of pitchers who were using steroids. If Bonds tests positive, then he should just get the same penalties as other players who test positive. Otherwise, he is innocent until proven guilty, and should get credit for what he has accomplished.
Aaron never got 1% of the media criticism that Bonds has received. The press hates Bonds, and has always hated him. I hope Bonds breaks Aaron's record.
Bonds has been a much better baseball player than Aaron was. Barry Bonds won seven MVP awards and finished second in the voting twice; Hank Aaron only narrowly won one MVP.
George writes:
Bonds has admitted to getting the "cream" and the "clear"There was a criminal investigation of Balco. If Bonds committed some crime, then he can be charged and prosecuted. If he violated some MLB rule, then MLB can suspend him or apply whatever other punishment is applicable. None of that has happened.
from Balco. He got his records by cheating. Are you condoning that?
While Bonds is suspected of using steroids, so are a lot of other hitters and pitchers. Somehow Bonds has done better than all those other suspected hitters. Maybe his records are all the more impressive if he got his home runs off of pitchers who were using steroids. If Bonds tests positive, then he should just get the same penalties as other players who test positive. Otherwise, he is innocent until proven guilty, and should get credit for what he has accomplished.
Tuesday, March 14, 2006
Genetic imprinting
Harvard evolutionary biologist David Haig has a theory about genomic imprinting:
Dr. Haig also made some predictions about the sorts of maternal defenses that have evolved. One of the most intriguing strategies he proposed was for mothers to shut down some of the genes in their own children.Funny how feminists can hate the idea that a father's genes might influence his children.
This strategy takes advantage of the fact that most of the genes we carry come in pairs. We inherit one copy from our mother and one from our father. In most cases, these pairs of genes behave identically. But in the past 15 years, scientists have identified more than 70 pairs of genes in which the copy from one parent never makes a protein. In some cases, a parent's gene is silenced only in one organ.
Scientists do not fully understand this process, known as genomic imprinting. ...
In many mammal species, females tend to stay in the groups where they are born and males leave. As a result, females tend to share more genes with other members of their group than males. A conflict may emerge between maternal and paternal genes over how the members of the group should act. Maternal genes may favor behavior that benefits the group. Paternal genes may favor behavior that benefits the individual. ...
Dr. Haig has enjoyed watching his theory mature and inspire other scientists. But he has also had to cope with a fair amount of hate mail. It comes from across the political spectrum, from abortion opponents to feminists who accuse him of trying to force patriarchy into biology.
"People seem to think, 'He must have a political agenda,'" Dr. Haig said. "But I'm not talking at all about conscious behaviors. I'm just interested in these mechanisms and why they evolved."
Monday, March 13, 2006
IQ in different academic fields
Someone has compiled a ranking of the IQ of grad students in different departments at elite universities, based on GRE scores. Here is Motl's version:
The precise numbers shouldn't be taken too seriously, but they do indicate the relative intelligence of people going into different fields.
- 130.0 Physics
- 129.0 Mathematics
- 128.5 Computer Science
- 128.0 Economics
- 127.5 Chemical engineering
- 127.0 Material science
- 126.0 Electrical engineering
- 125.5 Mechanical engineering
- 125.0 Philosophy
- 124.0 Chemistry
- 123.0 Earth sciences
- 122.0 Industrial engineering
- 122.0 Civil engineering
- 121.5 Biology
- 120.1 English/literature
- 120.0 Religion/theology
- 119.8 Political science
- 119.7 History
- 118.0 Art history
- 117.7 Anthropology/archeology
- 116.5 Architecture
- 116.0 Business
- 115.0 Sociology
- 114.0 Psychology
- 114.0 Medicine
- 112.0 Communication
- 109.0 Education
- 106.0 Public administration
Sunday, March 12, 2006
Slobodan Milosevic dies
Former Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic has died mysteriously in prison, and people are saying that he killed 200k people in the last great evil slaughter of the 20th century.
I don't know whether he was guilty or not. But I do know that Pres. Clinton was unable to convince either Congress or the UN to goto war against him, and went to war anyway.
After NATO captured Milosevic, it put him on a show trial to justify the NATO invasion. After a four-year trial, the three judges were still unable to make a decision. If NATO really had convincing proof of his guilt, then it should have only taken a couple of weeks to present in court.
I don't know whether he was guilty or not. But I do know that Pres. Clinton was unable to convince either Congress or the UN to goto war against him, and went to war anyway.
After NATO captured Milosevic, it put him on a show trial to justify the NATO invasion. After a four-year trial, the three judges were still unable to make a decision. If NATO really had convincing proof of his guilt, then it should have only taken a couple of weeks to present in court.
Fearmonger alert
NY Times reports:
Some leading climate scientists warn that we might be as few as 20 years away from a "tipping point," after which it will be too late to reverse catastrophic change.There is a sign of hope. In 20 years, we shouldn't have to listen to these kooks anymore.
Saturday, March 11, 2006
List of 20 Islamic inventions
UK paper:
From coffee to cheques and the three-course meal, the Muslim world has given us many innovations that we take for granted in daily life. As a new exhibition opens, Paul Vallely nominates 20 of the most influential- and identifies the men of genius behind them.It is an impressive list. The last invention was 300 years ago.
Friday, March 10, 2006
David Brooks not conservative
David Brooks cites some dubious observations from Annette Lareau like this:
Working-class child-rearing is different, Lareau writes. In these homes, there tends to be a much starker boundary between the adult world and the children's world. Parents think that the cares of adulthood will come soon enough and that children should be left alone to organize their own playtime. When a girl asks her mother to help her build a dollhouse out of boxes, the mother says no, "casually and without guilt," because playtime is deemed to be inconsequential ? a child's sphere, not an adult's. ...It is debatable whether moms should be helping their daughters build dollhouses, but some govt handouts are not likely to change the moms' attitudes towards dollhouses. This is just leftist fuzzy thinking that ill-defined social problems can somehow be solved by throwing govt money at them.
To help the worse-off parents, we should raise the earned-income tax credit to lessen their economic stress.
Fringe hate groups
A reader complains that if I am going to blame all Mohammedans for the actions of a radical few, then Christians should be blamed for not disavowing the Westboro Baptist Church.
The site appears to be some sort of joke. I couldn't make much sense of it. Whatever they are, I don't think that anyone will confuse them for mainstream Christians.
The site appears to be some sort of joke. I couldn't make much sense of it. Whatever they are, I don't think that anyone will confuse them for mainstream Christians.
Thursday, March 09, 2006
Arab-American on the Clash of Civilizations
Wafa Sultan Al-Jazeera TV:
Update: Now she is getting death threats from Mohammedans for telling the truth.
It is a clash between freedom and oppression, between democracy and dictatorship. It is a clash between human rights, on the one hand, and the violation of these rights, on other hand. It is a clash between those who treat women like beasts, and those who treat them like human beings. What we see today is not a clash of civilizations. Civilizations do not clash, but compete. ...This blog says that a jew planted a bomb once.
The Prophet of Islam said: "I was ordered to fight the people until they believe in Allah and His Messenger." When the Muslims divided the people into Muslims and non-Muslims, and called to fight the others until they believe in what they themselves believe, they started this clash, and began this war. In order to start this war, they must reexamine their Islamic books and curricula, which are full of calls for takfir and fighting the infidels. ...
We have not seen a single Jew blow himself up in a German restaurant. We have not seen a single Jew destroy a church. We have not seen a single Jew protest by killing people. The Muslims have turned three Buddha statues into rubble. We have not seen a single Buddhist burn down a Mosque, kill a Muslim, or burn down an embassy. Only the Muslims defend their beliefs by burning down churches, killing people, and destroying embassies. This path will not yield any results. The Muslims must ask themselves what they can do for humankind, before they demand that humankind respect them.
Update: Now she is getting death threats from Mohammedans for telling the truth.
Teacher monopoly
John Stossel says that the teachers unions are mad at him for saying things like this:
American fourth graders do well on international tests, but by high school, Americans have fallen behind kids in most other countries.The teachers unions always want more money, but money does not address the problems. Less money would be better.
The constant refrain that "public schools need more money" is nonsense. Many countries that spend significantly less on education do better than we do. School spending in America (adjusted for inflation) has more than tripled over the past 30 years, but national test scores are flat. The average per-pupil cost today is an astonishing $10,000 per student -- $200,000 per classroom! Think about how many teachers you could hire, and how much better you could do with that amount of money.
Wednesday, March 08, 2006
The feminist-judicial machine
Stephen Baskerville writes:
Phyllis Schlafly stands almost alone today among eminent public figures in warning against the feminist-judicial machine. She is calling for a re-evaluation of "no-fault" divorce, for the role and rights of fathers to be respected equally with those of mothers, and for shared parenting laws to discourage the use of children as weapons. "It's time to stop spending any more taxpayers' money to promote family dissolution and fatherless children."
Study Warns Women About Spring Break
AP Medical news:
CHICAGO - The American Medical Association is warning girls not to go wild during spring break. All but confirming what goes on in those "Girls Gone Wild" videos, 83 percent of college women and graduates surveyed by the AMA said spring break involves heavier-than-usual drinking, and 74 percent said the break results in increased sexual activity. ...I think that the AMA should stick to medicine.
"I think a lot of students wouldn't really pay that much attention to it," Fitzgerald said. "They would just be like, `Duh, that's why we do it.'"
About 30 percent of women surveyed said spring break trips with sun and alcohol are an essential part of college life.
Barry Bonds is innocent
The Frisco sportswriters are trashing Barry Bonds again, with gossip and hearsay from an ex-girlfriend and others. For some reason, the local sportswriters have always hated Barry Bonds, and they have been saying similar things for many years.
Bonds may very well have told the truth to the grand jury. If there were really good evidence that he lied, then he could be prosecuted. He has never tested positive or found guilty of anything, AFAIK, and he should get the benefit of the doubt.
I also think that Lance Armstrong has been unfairly maligned in the press, over unfounded drug accusations.
Bonds may very well have told the truth to the grand jury. If there were really good evidence that he lied, then he could be prosecuted. He has never tested positive or found guilty of anything, AFAIK, and he should get the benefit of the doubt.
I also think that Lance Armstrong has been unfairly maligned in the press, over unfounded drug accusations.
Tuesday, March 07, 2006
Phil Angelides
Phil Angelides is running for California governor, and is advertising that he will "double the number of high school counselors so kids are prepared for college."
The teachers union endorses him, saying that he has a vision for school funding that is not limited by resources.
No, I won't be voting for him. We need a governor who can stick to a budget, not brag about spending money we don't have on school counselors we don't need.
The teachers union endorses him, saying that he has a vision for school funding that is not limited by resources.
No, I won't be voting for him. We need a governor who can stick to a budget, not brag about spending money we don't have on school counselors we don't need.
Feminist ideals make wives morose
Meghan O'Rourke writes in Slate:
...the most interesting data may be that the women who strongly identify as progressive -- the 15 percent who agree most with feminist ideals -- have a harder time being happy than their peers, according to an analysis that has been provided exclusively to Slate. Feminist ideals, not domestic duties, seem to be what make wives morose. Progressive married women -- who should be enjoying some or all of the fruits that Freidan lobbied for -- are less happy, it would appear, than women who live as if Friedan never existed. ...O'Rourke's theories are dubious, but this really shouldn't be too hard to understand. Feminists are often unhappy about human nature, and frustrated that they cannot change it.
Across the board, progressive women are less likely to feel content, whether they are working or at home, and no matter how much they are making. ...
The study's authors, W. Bradford Wilcox and Steven Nock, speculate that fault-finding on the part of wives makes it hard for men to do the emotional work that stabilizes marriages. Meanwhile, traditionalist women -- a significant portion of whom are Christian -- expect less emotional work from their husbands, Wilcox and Nock speculate, which makes it easier for them to shake off frustrations, and less likely to nag.
Monday, March 06, 2006
Unpopular movies win
Oscar news:
One only has to look at the box office reciepts for 2005. Brokeback Mountain is 26th, Crash is 49th, Munich is 63rd, Good Night and Good Luck is 90th, Capote is 97th. Capote provided the Best Actor, Syriana, which was 58th, provided the best supporting actor, Constant Gardener, which was 79th, provided the best supporting actress. Only the best actress award, of the major awards, came from a movie that was moderately well recieved by the public, Walk the Line, which was 16th.Crash was a mediocre movie. I have not seen the others, and I do not plan to. The highest grossing movie of the year did not win any awards.
Book about pair of penguins
Chicago Tribune reports:
Savannah, Missouri -- A children's book about two male penguins that raise a baby penguin has been moved to the non-fiction section of two library branches after two parents complained it had homosexual undertones.Penguins exhibit instinctual pair-bonding, but that is a lot different from what is commonly called human homosexuality. There were no available females when Roy bonded with Silo. Roy later mated with a female.
The illustrated book, "And Tango Makes Three," is based on a true story of two male penguins, named Roy and Silo, who adopted an abandoned egg at New York City's Central Park Zoo in the late 1990s.
The feminist anti-kid crusade
Carey Roberts writes:
Call it one of those simple yet profound truths: only a father can help a boy become a man. And only a daddie can teach a girl about healthy male-female relationships.
Both dads and moms are unique and special. Maybe that's why dads love to mix it up with rough-and-tumble play. Perhaps it's why fathers teach kids a thing or two about risk-taking. And no doubt it has something to do with that tough love thing. ...
Not only is joint custody firmly rooted in the notion of gender equality, it's also ideal for kids. As Dr. Joan Kelly, former president of the Academy of Family Mediators concluded, shared parenting "is a desirable outcome which clearly is in the best interests of children and families." By 1991, over 40 states had shared parenting laws in place.
But the M.O.M.s -- Mothers Opposed to Men -- were not going to remain silent.
Sunday, March 05, 2006
No Two Alike: Human Nature
William Saletan writes:
Judith Rich Harris calls "No Two Alike" a "scientific detective story." The mystery is why people -- even identical twins who grow up in the same home with the same genes -- end up with different personalities. ...This is one of those subjects where people cling to their beliefs, regardless of the evidence.
Eight years ago, Harris's book "The Nurture Assumption" set academic psychology on fire by attacking the notion that parenting styles shape children. ...
Harris shreds popular theories of personality formation. Does home environment -- parenting style, marital harmony, the use or rejection of day care -- shape a child's personality, making her more agreeable, less aggressive or more extroverted? Nope. Research shows that twins don't turn out more alike if they're raised together than if they're raised apart. Nor do adoptive siblings. And when you compare apples to apples -- making sure that each parent-child unit in a study is as genetically related as any other -- being raised in one home rather than another, on average, makes no difference.
Friday, March 03, 2006
Smart people in science
Philip Greenspun writes:
Summers was deservedly castigated, but not for the right reasons. He claimed to be giving a comprehensive list of reasons why there weren't more women reaching the top jobs in the sciences. Yet Summers, an economist, left one out: Adjusted for IQ and working hours, jobs in science are the lowest paid in the United States.
Most people go to work primarily in order to earn a paycheck. Workers prefer a higher salary to a lower salary. Jobs in science pay far less than jobs in the professions and business held by women of similar ability. A lot of men are irrational, romantic, stubborn, and unwilling to admit that they've made a big mistake. With Occam's Razor, we should not need to bring in the FBI to solve the mystery of why there are more men than women who have chosen to stick with the choice that they made at age 18 to be a scientist or mathematician.
Thursday, March 02, 2006
Shared parenting fan
A father writes:
With regard to the shuttling kids argument ... anyone who has ever dealt the the 5-8pm visitation, realizes that THIS setup causes a great deal of shuttling. Not to mention, it gives the over all feel of the evening a "visitation" feel, rather than a "home" feel.He's right.
It is so amazing to me that we even need to discuss Shared Parenting. It should be a given!
If you want to follow a custody case, just to see how alive and well discrimination is in our family courts, visit my site www.5050parents.com.
Fan mail
Gabe writes:
Dude, I have no idea who you are, but I can't believe how much I agree with, like, every single post on your blog!Hmmm. I thought that I was writing a provocative blog. No one could agree with me that much.
Truly amazing.
I feel like I need to pay my bill now or something.
Props to you. Spectacular blog.
Wednesday, March 01, 2006
Veteran benefits
Sally Satel writes:
According to a report from its inspector general, the Department of Veterans Affairs is now paying compensation for post-traumatic stress disorder to nearly twice as many veterans as it did just six years ago, at an annual cost of $4.3 billion. What's more surprising is that the flood of recent applicants does not, for the most part, consist of young soldiers just returned from Iraq and Afghanistan. Rather they are Vietnam veterans in their 50's and 60's who claim to be psychologically crippled now by their service of decades ago.There are a lot of myths about Vietnam vets. Very few of them are psychologically crippled, if any.
Sunday, February 26, 2006
Museum images of Mohammad
LA Times reports:
George writes, "So why are they rioting?"
They are rioting because they believe in forcing infidels to submit, and they will not tolerate disrespect.
Thomas L. Friedman writes:
While lethal riots persist in the Middle East and American cartoonists and editors wring their hands over what it means to publish pictures of Muhammad, the Western world's curators of Islamic art whisper and wonder.This is more evidence that Islam does not forbid images of Mohammad.
As they understand it, the Koran does not forbid representations of Muhammad, though other revered texts have led millions of Muslims to scorn the idea. They know that many Islamic artists have taken on the subject. And they know that pictures of Muhammad -- not caricatures, but respectful representations, executed by and for Muslims, sometimes with the prophet's face shrouded by a veil, sometimes not -- can be found in museums throughout Europe and North America. ... The largest collection of such images, experts say, is probably that of the Topkapi Museum in Istanbul.
George writes, "So why are they rioting?"
They are rioting because they believe in forcing infidels to submit, and they will not tolerate disrespect.
Thomas L. Friedman writes:
People across the world still look to our example of pluralism, like no other. If we go Dark Ages, if we go down the road of pitch-fork-wielding xenophobes, then the whole world will go Dark Ages.Only Mohammedans want to go back to the Dark Ages.
Psychotherapy is unscientific
Psychoanalyst Adam Phillips writes:
Psychotherapy is having yet another identity crisis. It has manifested itself in two recent trends in the profession in America: the first involves trying to make therapy into more of a "hard science" by putting a new emphasis on measurable factors; the other is a growing belief among therapists that the standard practice of using talk therapy to discover traumas in a patient's past is not only unnecessary but can be injurious. ...He thinks that psychotherapy can become useful without being scientific.
If you have an eye test, if you buy a car, there are certain things you are entitled to expect. Your money buys you some minimal guarantees, some reliable results. The honest psychotherapist can provide no comparable assurances. She can promise only an informed willingness to listen, and the possibility of helpful comment.
Friday, February 24, 2006
Quantify the risk
The Emergent Chaos blog cites this story:
The district court expressly rejected the expert testimony because "the affidavit of plaintiffs' expert conclusorily posits that plaintiff's risk of identity fraud is significantly increased without quantifying the risk."The judge has a point. Most statements about risk are meaningless because the risk is not quantified.
Thursday, February 23, 2006
Teaching kids to eat
Alice Waters writes:
Schools should not just serve food; they should teach it in an interactive, hands-on way, as an academic subject. Children's eating habits stay with them for the rest of their lives. ...Teaching nothing would be better than teaching nonsense. It is ridiculous to teach that school lunches become more nutritious by banning whole milk.
We can try to improve diets all we want by making school lunches more nutritious and by getting vending machines out of the hallways, but that gets us only partway there. For example, New York City has just banned whole milk in its public schools. It's a courageous first step, but how can we be sure students will drink healthier milk just because it's offered to them, let alone understand what lifelong nourishment is all about?
Europeans not marrying
British news:
The proportion of children born outside marriage in the UK has leapt from 12% in 1980 to 42% in 2004, according to the Office for National Statistics.Sweden and France had the highest rates.
In contrast, 15 other EU countries had an estimated average of 33%, the annual ONS' Social Trends report said.
Tuesday, February 21, 2006
Italian rape law
CNN reports:
ROME, Italy (Reuters) -- Sexually abusing a teenager is less serious a crime if the girl is not a virgin, Italy's higher court said on Friday in a controversial ruling that immediately drew a barrage of criticism. ...Feminist dogma says that all rape is the same, but I don't agree. I say that raping a virgin is a worse crime than raping a slut, and stranger rape is worse than date rape, and almost any rape is worse than marital rape.
The supreme court is no stranger to controversial judgments.
In recent years it has ruled that "an isolated and impulsive" pat on a woman's buttocks at work did not constitute sexual harassment, and returned a verdict that a woman could not have been raped because she was wearing skin-tight jeans.
Monday, February 20, 2006
No free speech in Austria
Austria news:
VIENNA, Feb. 20 (AP) ? The British historian David Irving on Monday pleaded guilty to denying the Holocaust and was sentenced to three years in prison. He conceded that he was wrong when he said there were no Nazi gas chambers at the Auschwitz death camp.I wonder how the Europeans will explain this to the Mohammedans who are upset about Danish cartoons. Wouldn't it be a lot easier just to prove that Irving was wrong?
Mr. Irving, 67, has been in custody since Nov. 11, when he was arrested in the southern province of Styria on charges stemming from two speeches he gave in Austria in 1989 in which he was accused of denying the Nazis' annihilation of six million Jews. He has contended that most of those who died at camps like Auschwitz were not executed, but instead succumbed to diseases like typhus.
School bans game of tag
Fox News reports:
A Santa Monica elementary school has banned the game of tag, once synonymous with youth and innocence, because they say it creates self-esteem issues among weaker and slower children.I wonder how they ever decide to approve anything.
"We had some children who were not playing 'it' appropriately. How do you differentiate between those that are playing correctly and those that aren't?" asked Franklin Elementary School Principal Pat Samarge.
Warning foreign women about American men
Wendy McElroy writes:
Maybe that's next. If so, the law ought to be made more sex-neutral and provide pertinent info to the man, such as current or previous pregnancies as well as how and when they terminated.
The Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), signed by President Bush on January 5th, contains an almost unnoticed attachment. Subtitle D, also known as the International Marriage Broker Regulation Act of 2005 (IMBA), will become law when VAWA is enacted. ... the IMBA requires American men who wish to correspond with foreign women through private for-profit matchmaking agencies to first provide those businesses with their police records and other personal information to be turned over to the women.This is another silly nanny state law. I don't know why anyone wants to give foreigners more rights than Americans. When an American women goes out on a date with a man, no one requires the man to notify her of his arrest record.
An international broker cannot provide contact or general information on a foreign woman to an American man unless that broker first collects and discloses to the woman the following information about the man:
--every state of residence since the age of 18;
--current or previous marriages as well as how and when they terminated;
--information on children under 18;
--any arrest or conviction related to controlled substances, alcohol or prostitution, making no distinction on arrests not leading to conviction;
--any court orders, including temporary restraining orders which are notoriously easy to procure;
--any arrest or conviction for crimes ranging from "homicide" to "child neglect";
--any arrest or conviction for "similar activity in violation of Federal, State or local criminal law" without specifying what "similar" means.
Maybe that's next. If so, the law ought to be made more sex-neutral and provide pertinent info to the man, such as current or previous pregnancies as well as how and when they terminated.
Sunday, February 19, 2006
Kids influencing parents
NY Times reports:
These statistics are curious because it would seem that correlation implies causation. It wouldn't necessarily mean that liberal politics is better for girls, but might mean that people have that perception.
Today, though, the gender gap -- that men lean right and women lean left -- has become a political truism, and a series of new studies suggests that gender plays an even bigger role in politics than many believed. Having a son tends to make parents more conservative, it appears, while a daughter makes them more liberal. The parental has become the political.Steven E. Landsburg says that daughters cause divorce.
These statistics are curious because it would seem that correlation implies causation. It wouldn't necessarily mean that liberal politics is better for girls, but might mean that people have that perception.
Americans on sleeping pills
NY Times reports:
With complaints of insomnia mounting, and marketing by drug companies becoming ever more ubiquitous, we are turning in increasing numbers to drugs like Ambien and Lunesta. According to a recent report from the research company IMS Health, pharmacists in the United States filled some 42 million prescriptions for sleeping pills last year, a rise of nearly 60 percent since 2000.This is about 1 out of every 6 adults. I had no idea that so many people take sleeping pills.
Saturday, February 18, 2006
Hockey team loses
Andy writes:
Here we go again. The men's Olympic hockey team can be expected to be lousy, thanks to Title IX quotas. But the women's Olympic hockey team should be great, right, with all the new "opportunities" for women created by Title IX?The Swiss men's team is on a roll, beating the Czechs and Canada.
Nope. Title IX quotas are bad for women as well as men, because it distorts funding to a quota-based, numeric system.
Our women's hockey team was beaten by the mighty nation of Sweden last night.
Friday, February 17, 2006
Enemies of Larry Summers
More sniping at Harvard:
Over lunch not long after Summers took over the presidency in 2001, Ellison said, Summers suggested that some funds should be moved from a sociology program to the Kennedy School, home to many economists and political scientists. "President Summers asked me, didn't I agree that, in general, economists are smarter than political scientists, and political scientists are smarter than sociologists?" Ellison said. "To which I laughed nervously and didn't reply."Ellison is an anthropologist who was trying to hold onto some power as a Harvard dean. The Czech physicist Motl says:
In a debate with the ex-dean Ellison, the president made a remark that seems absolutely obvious to The Reference Frame - namely that the economists are smarter, in average, than the political scientists who are smarter, in average, than the sociologists. In my opinion, there can't be any reasonable doubt about the first statement and the second statement is likely to be true.Yes, and you'll find much smarter people in the hard sciences.
The economists represent the only field in the list that tries to study the true mechanisms that are actually relevant for the society by scientific methods - methods that attempt to be as sharp and quantitative as possible. These methods should be based on actual research as opposed to philosophical preconceptions. And sometimes they even have scientific results. If you allow me to add an example, the Czech President is an economist and one of the brightest people in the nation.
The other fields are as non-quantitative as possible and they are satisfied with vague or even scientifically vacuous verbal proclamations. It's almost always the case that the scholars in these other fields become prominent because they say something that is politically convenient for sufficiently large groups of people. The selection in social sciences is political, not scientific, in nature.
Thursday, February 16, 2006
Math needs new image
The Si Valley paper says:
I've always wondered how Cohen could make such idiotic argument. His columns are widely published, and he appears on TV a lot. And yet, I don't think that I've ever heard him give a well-reasoned argument. His column explains a lot.
The Bush Administration wants to make math and science cool.Meanwhile, on the op-ed page in the same paper, Richard Cohen says:
Carlos Gutierrez, U.S. Commerce Secretary, visiting Silicon Valley and Stanford University on Wednesday, said that along with President Bush's recently announced American Competitiveness Initiative, there needs to be a change in American culture -- to embrace inventors and scientists, in the same way Americans worship athletes or pop stars.
Gutierrez was in the valley to promote the competitiveness initiative, a 10-year, $136 billion program. Bush unveiled the plan in his State of the Union address last month. It calls for a doubling in federal funding for basic research in physical sciences, money for improving math and science education in elementary and secondary schools, and a permanent extension of the research and development tax credits for companies.
The proposal also includes starting a "Math Now" program to promote math among elementary and middle school students.
I confess to be one of those people who hate math. I can do my basic arithmetic all right (although not percentages) but I flunked algebra (once), ...Apparently Cohen never learned what a proof is, as getting a location wrong says nothing about reasoning.
Sooner or later someone's going to tell you that algebra teaches reasoning. This is a lie propagated by, among others, algebra teachers. Writing is the highest form of reasoning. This is a fact. Algebra is not. The proof of this, Gabriela, is all the people in my high school who were whizzes at math but did not know a thing about history and could not write a readable English sentence. I can cite Shelly, whose last name will not be mentioned, who aced algebra but when called to the board in geography class, located the Sahara Desert right where the Gobi usually is. She was off by a whole continent.
I've always wondered how Cohen could make such idiotic argument. His columns are widely published, and he appears on TV a lot. And yet, I don't think that I've ever heard him give a well-reasoned argument. His column explains a lot.
Wednesday, February 15, 2006
Tuesday, February 14, 2006
Shared parenting
Various states are considering child custody reform. For example, here is a recent Michigan proposal. The idea is that the legislature would require the family courts to start with a rebuttable presumption of shared child custody in divorce cases.
The opposition comes from lawyers, feminists, and others. The lawyers don't like shared custody because it reduces the need for litigation. They'll argue that every case is individual and that judges need maximum discretion because then lawyers are needed for a high-stakes court dispute. The feminists want women to be in charge and to get more support payments, and they get that when mothers get primary custody. Various others profit from a bias towards mother custody, because it maximizes the transfer payments.
There are also some conservatives who oppose shared custody, and that is harder to understand. I will look at specific arguments from them. (These arguments are taken directly from a private letter, but I am not at liberty to post it.)
Argument: Most parents do not split responsibilities 50-50.
It is certainly true that mothers change most of the diapers, but parental responsibilities encompass much more than that. If a father works two jobs to support his family, and doesn't play patty-cake with his kids all afternoon, then are you going to say that he is not living up to his responsibilities?
In my experience, most parents do split their parenting responsibilities fairly evenly. They don't take identical roles, for various reasons, but they both contribute in crucial ways. It is only by devaluing the father's role could anyone say that the mother performs 85% of the parenting responsibilities.
Argument: Shuttling kids is not conducive to order and stability
The order and stability that kids crave is having two parents who are integral parts of their lives. They are much more attached to their parents than their beds. Those who argue for mother custody often talk about how a child may be attached to her toys and dolls, but the argument depends on the notion that a child's attachments to some material things is more important that her attachment to her parents. They are not.
Some divorced parents hand off their kids daily; some do it weekly; and some use other schedules. Shared parenting does not have to necessarily follow any particular schedule. Some schedules actually involve less shuttling that the typical mother custody arrangement in which the father gets visitation every other weekend.
Sometimes there are complaints about the "dangers of lost homework", but the empirical evidence is that kids do better in school when fathers share custody, than when raised by single mothers. Problems coordinating things like homework are relatively minor compared to the enormous gains from having both parents actively raising the kids.
Argument: Shared custody is not in the best interest of the child
Some argue that judges need the discretion to award custody in the child's best interest, and that is usually not shared parenting. Anyone who thinks that judges are making decisions based on the best interest of the child (BIOTC) is delusional. BIOTC is just a buzz phrase that courts use to justify doing whatever they want to do. I defy anyone to show me one single case in the USA that was actually decided based on BIOTC.
I happen to be an expert in optimization theory. To determine the BIOC, one must, as a minimum: identify the interests of the children; adopt a methodology for measuring and consolidating those interests into a best interest; define the range of custody alternatives; and evaluate and compare those alternatives according to the consolidated best interest. These things are never done by the family court.
Argument: Fathers should get liberal visitation
This is perhaps the most offensive argument. Use of this language shows a refusal to accept fathers as having a true parenting role. Some mothers just want fathers to be visitors (and financial providers). They will let them be occasional babysitters, but not be the father figures that kids really need.
Children do best when they have a mother and a father, and when both the mother and father have genuine parenting roles.
Argument: Even Dobson's Focus on the Family is against shared parenting
James Dobson's Focus on the Family does indeed have a position paper against shared parenting. It is not clear exactly what the status of this position paper is, as it is undated, unsigned, unpublished, and not on Dobson's web site. I assume that the paper is authentic, but it may include views that Dobson is unwilling to put his reputation behind. You can find the position paper here, along with a good rebuttal by Dr. Fink.
As you can see from Dr. Fink's rebuttal, Dobson relies heavily on discredited research from Judith Wallerstein. Wallerstein's so-called research has done a lot of damage. She wrote (about her own work): "Research by Drs. Judith Wallerstein and Joan Berlin Kelly revealed that approximately 50 percent of mothers either saw no value in the father's contact with his children and actively tried to sabotage it, or resented the father's contact." (Wallerstein, Surviving the Breakup, HarperCollins, 1996, p.125).
Similar opinions by Wallerstein persuaded the California supreme court in 1996 to allow custodial parents (usually the mothers) to move their children permanently away from the fathers for just about any reason. Her arguments to the court are rebutted here: The Burgess Decision and the Wallerstein Brief, by Richard A. Gardner. M.D., Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 26(3):425-431, 1998.
Contrary to Wallerstein's opinions, the scientific research studies show overwhelmingly that shared custody works better than mother custody. Dobson's paper tries to down play Bauserman's meta-analysis because of non-uniformity in the cited studies, because some of the cited studies were unpublished Ph.D. theses, and because some of Bauserman's other research has been disturbing. But Bauserman's results have been confirmed by everyone who has looked. See for example, Father and Child Reunion by Warren Farrell (Penguin, 2001). Farrell looked at studies that tried to measure child custody outcomes a dozen different ways, and found that shared parenting did better than mother custody on every single one. He persuasively explains just why fathers are so important to their children.
It is baffling how any pro-family organization could be against shared parenting. The law should minimize the incentives for divorce, and it should help maintain family relationships to the extent practical. With today's unilateral divorces, any spouse can get divorced at any time for any reason, but there is no reason why the court should step in and effectively divorce the kids from one of the parents.
Conservatives should also oppose the intervention of judges into routine child-rearing decisions. That is what usually happens now when there is a custody trial or any other court procedure that is supposedly based on the BIOTC. Conservatives should favor leaving those decisions in the hands of the parents. And I mean both parents. The courts should not interfere unless there is criminal child abuse or something like that. Conservatives are adamantly against government interference in child-rearing by a married couple, and they should similarly object to interference with a divorced couple. The surest way to accomplish that is to have a statutory presumption of 50-50 custody.
Even the US Supreme Court has repeatedly declared that parents have a fundamental constitutional right to make decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children. This was reaffirmed as recently as 2000 in Troxel v. Granville.
In sum, a presumption of shared custody is the best way, whether one looks at empirical evidence, conservative values, or what is good for children.
The opposition comes from lawyers, feminists, and others. The lawyers don't like shared custody because it reduces the need for litigation. They'll argue that every case is individual and that judges need maximum discretion because then lawyers are needed for a high-stakes court dispute. The feminists want women to be in charge and to get more support payments, and they get that when mothers get primary custody. Various others profit from a bias towards mother custody, because it maximizes the transfer payments.
There are also some conservatives who oppose shared custody, and that is harder to understand. I will look at specific arguments from them. (These arguments are taken directly from a private letter, but I am not at liberty to post it.)
Argument: Most parents do not split responsibilities 50-50.
It is certainly true that mothers change most of the diapers, but parental responsibilities encompass much more than that. If a father works two jobs to support his family, and doesn't play patty-cake with his kids all afternoon, then are you going to say that he is not living up to his responsibilities?
In my experience, most parents do split their parenting responsibilities fairly evenly. They don't take identical roles, for various reasons, but they both contribute in crucial ways. It is only by devaluing the father's role could anyone say that the mother performs 85% of the parenting responsibilities.
Argument: Shuttling kids is not conducive to order and stability
The order and stability that kids crave is having two parents who are integral parts of their lives. They are much more attached to their parents than their beds. Those who argue for mother custody often talk about how a child may be attached to her toys and dolls, but the argument depends on the notion that a child's attachments to some material things is more important that her attachment to her parents. They are not.
Some divorced parents hand off their kids daily; some do it weekly; and some use other schedules. Shared parenting does not have to necessarily follow any particular schedule. Some schedules actually involve less shuttling that the typical mother custody arrangement in which the father gets visitation every other weekend.
Sometimes there are complaints about the "dangers of lost homework", but the empirical evidence is that kids do better in school when fathers share custody, than when raised by single mothers. Problems coordinating things like homework are relatively minor compared to the enormous gains from having both parents actively raising the kids.
Argument: Shared custody is not in the best interest of the child
Some argue that judges need the discretion to award custody in the child's best interest, and that is usually not shared parenting. Anyone who thinks that judges are making decisions based on the best interest of the child (BIOTC) is delusional. BIOTC is just a buzz phrase that courts use to justify doing whatever they want to do. I defy anyone to show me one single case in the USA that was actually decided based on BIOTC.
I happen to be an expert in optimization theory. To determine the BIOC, one must, as a minimum: identify the interests of the children; adopt a methodology for measuring and consolidating those interests into a best interest; define the range of custody alternatives; and evaluate and compare those alternatives according to the consolidated best interest. These things are never done by the family court.
Argument: Fathers should get liberal visitation
This is perhaps the most offensive argument. Use of this language shows a refusal to accept fathers as having a true parenting role. Some mothers just want fathers to be visitors (and financial providers). They will let them be occasional babysitters, but not be the father figures that kids really need.
Children do best when they have a mother and a father, and when both the mother and father have genuine parenting roles.
Argument: Even Dobson's Focus on the Family is against shared parenting
James Dobson's Focus on the Family does indeed have a position paper against shared parenting. It is not clear exactly what the status of this position paper is, as it is undated, unsigned, unpublished, and not on Dobson's web site. I assume that the paper is authentic, but it may include views that Dobson is unwilling to put his reputation behind. You can find the position paper here, along with a good rebuttal by Dr. Fink.
As you can see from Dr. Fink's rebuttal, Dobson relies heavily on discredited research from Judith Wallerstein. Wallerstein's so-called research has done a lot of damage. She wrote (about her own work): "Research by Drs. Judith Wallerstein and Joan Berlin Kelly revealed that approximately 50 percent of mothers either saw no value in the father's contact with his children and actively tried to sabotage it, or resented the father's contact." (Wallerstein, Surviving the Breakup, HarperCollins, 1996, p.125).
Similar opinions by Wallerstein persuaded the California supreme court in 1996 to allow custodial parents (usually the mothers) to move their children permanently away from the fathers for just about any reason. Her arguments to the court are rebutted here: The Burgess Decision and the Wallerstein Brief, by Richard A. Gardner. M.D., Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 26(3):425-431, 1998.
Contrary to Wallerstein's opinions, the scientific research studies show overwhelmingly that shared custody works better than mother custody. Dobson's paper tries to down play Bauserman's meta-analysis because of non-uniformity in the cited studies, because some of the cited studies were unpublished Ph.D. theses, and because some of Bauserman's other research has been disturbing. But Bauserman's results have been confirmed by everyone who has looked. See for example, Father and Child Reunion by Warren Farrell (Penguin, 2001). Farrell looked at studies that tried to measure child custody outcomes a dozen different ways, and found that shared parenting did better than mother custody on every single one. He persuasively explains just why fathers are so important to their children.
It is baffling how any pro-family organization could be against shared parenting. The law should minimize the incentives for divorce, and it should help maintain family relationships to the extent practical. With today's unilateral divorces, any spouse can get divorced at any time for any reason, but there is no reason why the court should step in and effectively divorce the kids from one of the parents.
Conservatives should also oppose the intervention of judges into routine child-rearing decisions. That is what usually happens now when there is a custody trial or any other court procedure that is supposedly based on the BIOTC. Conservatives should favor leaving those decisions in the hands of the parents. And I mean both parents. The courts should not interfere unless there is criminal child abuse or something like that. Conservatives are adamantly against government interference in child-rearing by a married couple, and they should similarly object to interference with a divorced couple. The surest way to accomplish that is to have a statutory presumption of 50-50 custody.
Even the US Supreme Court has repeatedly declared that parents have a fundamental constitutional right to make decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children. This was reaffirmed as recently as 2000 in Troxel v. Granville.
In sum, a presumption of shared custody is the best way, whether one looks at empirical evidence, conservative values, or what is good for children.
Monday, February 13, 2006
The Secret Cause of Flame Wars
Wired reports:
According to recent research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, I've only a 50-50 chance of ascertaining the tone of any e-mail message. The study also shows that people think they've correctly interpreted the tone of e-mails they receive 90 percent of the time.Epley has his theory for how people could be so mistaken. My theory is that most people falsely believe that they have mind-reading capabilities.
"That's how flame wars get started," says psychologist Nicholas Epley of the University of Chicago, who conducted the research with Justin Kruger of New York University. "People in our study were convinced they've accurately understood the tone of an e-mail message when in fact their odds are no better than chance," says Epley.
The researchers took 30 pairs of undergraduate students and gave each one a list of 20 statements about topics like campus food or the weather. Assuming either a serious or sarcastic tone, one member of each pair e-mailed the statements to his or her partner. The partners then guessed the intended tone and indicated how confident they were in their answers.
Those who sent the messages predicted that nearly 80 percent of the time their partners would correctly interpret the tone. In fact the recipients got it right just over 50 percent of the time.
Sunday, February 12, 2006
Arguments against profiling
John Allen Paulos gives mathematical arguments against profiling, and why we should pass gun control laws instead.
He also gives legalistic constitutional arguments, where he is a little out of his field.
Security expert Bruce Schneier frequently gives arguments against profiling. Here he attacks the related idea of issued preferred IDs to certain airline passengers in the Trusted Traveler program.
These arguments are fallacious. I wonder how these guys think that law enforcement officials ever catch anyone, if they cannot make any tentative conclusions about who is suspicious.
One argument says that security, like a chain, is only as strong as its weakest link. So unless everyone is treated the same, the bad guys will just act like whomever is the least suspicious, and therefore minimize the chance of getting caught.
The flaw is that not all strategies are equally available to the bad guys. Some people are a lot easier to recruit for criminal acts than others.
He also gives legalistic constitutional arguments, where he is a little out of his field.
Security expert Bruce Schneier frequently gives arguments against profiling. Here he attacks the related idea of issued preferred IDs to certain airline passengers in the Trusted Traveler program.
These arguments are fallacious. I wonder how these guys think that law enforcement officials ever catch anyone, if they cannot make any tentative conclusions about who is suspicious.
One argument says that security, like a chain, is only as strong as its weakest link. So unless everyone is treated the same, the bad guys will just act like whomever is the least suspicious, and therefore minimize the chance of getting caught.
The flaw is that not all strategies are equally available to the bad guys. Some people are a lot easier to recruit for criminal acts than others.
Saturday, February 11, 2006
Genes influence reading skills
Psychology research:
Genetics can play a bigger role in determining a child's reading ability than teaching, an Australian researcher says.I don't think that bed-time stories are really intended to make up for a genetic bad deal.
An international study showed some children were born with "an unfortunate deal of the genetic deck" when it comes to reading skills, said study co-author Brian Byrne, professor of psychology at the University of New England in northern NSW.
No "magic bullet" of encouragement and tutoring would fully improve their reading abilities, he said.
Published in the latest issue of the British-based Journal of Research in Reading, the study showed the influence of parents reading to their children diminished significantly a year or so after they started school. ...
The research examined more than 600 pairs of identical and non-identical twins in Australia, the United States, Norway and Sweden from different racial and socio-economic backgrounds.
Byrne said bed-time stories early in a child's life, encouragement to read and remedial teaching would never totally make up for a child's genetic "bad deal".
Sex is what women want
The New York Daily News reports:
Gone are the times when women became starry eyed if their lovers gifted them flowers, emotional cards or chocolates on Valentine's Day. A new poll suggests that ladies today prefer to move straight to the bedroom and forgo all the nuances of a mushy courtship.We need more research done by condom makers.
More than 52 percent of American women said they wanted to have sex on the most romantic day of the year, according to a survey sponsered by a condom company.
While 45 percent were looking for a greeting card, 41 percent were hoping for flowers and a surprisingly low 30 percentcounting on chocolates. ...
The craving for some Valentine's Day action was highest among younger women, with 76 percent of those 18 to 34 saying they wanted sex, compared with just 24 percent of those older than 55, according to the poll, paid for by LifeStyles condoms.
Thursday, February 09, 2006
Boys dominate big kiddie movies
AP reports:
He might be right. A group called Dads & Daughters should have a dad as a spokesman, not a Hollywood actress. My daughters find plenty of movies for children with female role models. For example, they like movies like Cinderella, Shirley Temple movies, The Wizard of Oz, and Eloise at Christmastime. The leading child actor is Hollywood today is a girl named Dakota Fanning.
LOS ANGELES - Male characters outnumbered females 3-to-1 overall in top-grossing G-rated films from 1990 to 2004, according to a study whose sponsors say the disparity diminishes the importance of women in children's eyes.John sarcastically suggests that "Dads & Daughters" may be a feminist group in disguise.
"We're showing kids a world that's very scantly populated with women and female characters," said actress Geena Davis, founder of See Jane, a program of the advocacy group Dads & Daughters that encourages balanced gender representation in entertainment for children.
He might be right. A group called Dads & Daughters should have a dad as a spokesman, not a Hollywood actress. My daughters find plenty of movies for children with female role models. For example, they like movies like Cinderella, Shirley Temple movies, The Wizard of Oz, and Eloise at Christmastime. The leading child actor is Hollywood today is a girl named Dakota Fanning.
"It's important for what kids watch that as far as possible, they see the real world reflected, to see men and women, boys and girls, sharing the space," said Davis, co-star of the female-empowerment film "Thelma & Louise" and star of TV's "Commander in Chief" in which she plays the U.S. president. "They should see female characters taking up half the planet, which we do."There are several Geena Davis movies that I'd recommend, but not those. The female empowerment in Thelma & Louise is murder and suicide, and is not a good example for my kids. I watched a couple of episodes of Davis's TV show, and she seemed like a lousy president to me. She was unable to control her own staff, and at the same time, she was recklessly committing to ill-considered overseas military adventures.
Joe Kelly, co-founder of Dads & Daughters, said as much as he loves "Toy Story," the study made him think about the movie differently. The movie has a positive message about two characters -- Tom Hanks' Woody and Tim Allen's Buzz Lightyear -- overcoming their differences and working together, but it does have a flaw, Kelly said.Toy Story was obviously created to appeal to both boys and girls. The main (human) character is a boy who plays with dolls, and the dolls spring to life when no one is watching. It seemed like a clever compromise to me. If the movie had been about a girl who plays with dolls, then it would have immediately lost 50% of the market.
Wednesday, February 08, 2006
Koran allows cartoons
Amir Taheri writes in a WSJ op-ed:
There is no Quranic injunction against images, whether of Muhammad or anyone else. When it spread into the Levant, Islam came into contact with a version of Christianity that was militantly iconoclastic. ... and the claim that a ban on images is "an absolute principle of Islam" is purely political.I believe that most of the news stories are incorrect when they try to describe the motives of the Mohammedan cartoon protesters. They shouldn't try to read minds, and certainly not Mohammedan minds.
The claim that the ban on depicting Muhammad and other prophets is an absolute principle of Islam is also refuted by history. Many portraits of Muhammad have been drawn by Muslim artists, often commissioned by Muslim rulers. ...
The truth is that Islam has always had a sense of humor and has never called for chopping heads as the answer to satirists. Muhammad himself pardoned a famous Meccan poet who had lampooned him for more than a decade.
Low-fat diet is worthless
Gina Kolata writes:
The largest study ever to ask whether a low-fat diet reduces the risk of getting cancer or heart disease has found that the diet has no effect. ... those assigned to a low-fat diet had the same rates of breast cancer, colon cancer, heart attacks and strokes as those who ate whatever they pleased, researchers are reporting today. ...Supposed experts have been telling us for years that eating fat was bad, and that eater fiber is good, for various reasons. In fact, there is very little scientific evidence that any American diet is better than any other.
"These studies are revolutionary," said Dr. Jules Hirsch, physician in chief emeritus at Rockefeller University in New York City, who has spent a lifetime studying the effects of diets on weight and health. "They should put a stop to this era of thinking that we have all the information we need to change the whole national diet and make everybody healthy." ...
For decades, many scientists have said, and many members of the public have believed, that what people eat -- the composition of the diet -- determines how likely they are to get a chronic disease. But that has been hard to prove. Studies of dietary fiber and colon cancer failed to find that fiber was protective, and studies of vitamins thought to protect against cancer failed to show an effect.
Tuesday, February 07, 2006
Cult of political correctness
Peter A. Lawrence wrote an essay on Men, Women, and Ghosts in Science, but it was ideologically unacceptable:
An academic row has erupted after one of the world's leading scientific journals refused to publish an article which claims that men and women think differently. ...Actually, the article does give suggestions for how to deal with the "gender issue". He says:
In his paper, Mr Lawrence questioned why, when 60 per cent of biology students are female, only 10 per go on to become professors. ...
But Mr Lawrence dismissed "the cult of political correctness" that insists men and women are "equivalent, identical even" and argued that "men and women are born different".
The journal considered the article for seven months and, after making a number of changes, gave Mr Lawrence a publication date, proofs and a chance to order reprints.
But at the last minute he received an e-mail from Donald Kennedy, the editor-in-chief, in which he said that the journal was not going to publish the article.
The piece "did not, at least for us, lead to a clear strategy about how to deal with the gender issue," said Kennedy. ...
Science is reeling from having published two papers that contained the most notorious fraud of recent years, Prof Hwang Woo-Suk's human embryonic stem cell research.
Over two years ago, the journal was also criticised for trying to influence a Congressional debate by publishing a widely reported paper linking the drug ecstasy to brain damage, which was subsequently retracted.
Some have a dream that, one fine day, there will be equal numbers of men and women in all jobs, including those in scientific research. But I think this dream is Utopian; it assumes that if all doors were opened and all discrimination ended, the different sexes would be professionally indistinguishable. The dream is sustained by a cult of political correctness that ignores the facts of life -- and thrives only because the human mind likes to bury experience as it builds beliefs. Here I will argue, as others have many times before, that men and women are born different. ...What the editors don't like is his statement that the "dream is Utopian". Martin Luther King had a dream, and no one likes to be told that his utopian dream is impossible.
I have argued that reducing the premium we give to aggression would, in several different ways, lead to more women in science and also to better science. Even so, in this Utopia, I think that far less than 50% of top physicists would be women (and far less than 50% of top professors of literature would be men). But I don't think that would matter -- we would be making better use of the diverse qualities of people. Both women and men might accept that although there is much overlap in the two populations, we are constitutionally different -- a diversity we should be able to celebrate and discuss openly. Both women and men should be leading such discussions with pride.
Monday, February 06, 2006
Penetrative intercourse only
UK news:
New Scientist magazine reports that Stuart Brody, a psychologist at the University of Paisley, found having sex can help keep stress at bay.I'd be skeptical, like "Dr Peter Bull", but apparently there are other studies with similar results.
However, only penetrative intercourse did the trick - other forms of sex had no impact on stress levels at all. ...
Dr Brody found that the effect remained even after taking differences in personality and other health-related factors into account.
He told the BBC News website it was possible the calming effect was linked to the stimulation of a wide variety of nerves which takes place during heterosexual intercourse, but not other forms of sex. ...
Professor Brody said it made sense in evolutionary terms for standard heterosexual sexual intercourse to be associated with a wide range of positive effects on behaviour.
He said: "A growing body of research shows that it is specifically intercourse, and not other sexual behaviours, whether alone or with a partner, that is associated with a broad range of psychological and physiological benefits.
Sunday, February 05, 2006
Detecting liars
NY Times Magazine says:
This is yet another example of how most people suffer from delusions that they can read other peoples' minds. They cannot.
Most people think they're good at spotting liars, but studies show otherwise. A very small minority of people, probably fewer than 5 percent, seem to have some innate ability to sniff out deception with accuracy. But in general, even professional lie-catchers, like judges and customs officials, perform, when tested, at a level not much better than chance. In other words, even the experts would have been right almost as often if they had just flipped a coin.The article has much more about the science of lie detection.
This is yet another example of how most people suffer from delusions that they can read other peoples' minds. They cannot.
Convicted and exonerated
Here is some data on Americans who are falsely convicted. No one who has been executed in recent decades was later shown to be innocent. Joshua Marquis says:
Common sense would indicate that many more innocent people are convicted. Human beings are fallible. Judges, juries, prosecutors, cops, and others have various biases. But there is no hard data showing that a significant number of people are falsely convicted.
Only 14 Americans who were once on death row have been exonerated by DNA evidence alone. ... In the Winter 2005 Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, a group led by Samuel Gross, a law professor at the University of Michigan, published an exhaustive study of exonerations around the country from 1989 to 2003 in cases ranging from robbery to capital murder. They were able to document only 340 inmates who were eventually freed. (They counted cases where defendants were retried after an initial conviction and subsequently found not guilty as "exonerations.")This is an extremely small rate of exonerations, and the rate is likely to go down in the future. Only in the last 10 years have DNA exonerations been possible because the DNA evidence was not available at trial.
Common sense would indicate that many more innocent people are convicted. Human beings are fallible. Judges, juries, prosecutors, cops, and others have various biases. But there is no hard data showing that a significant number of people are falsely convicted.
Saturday, February 04, 2006
Embassies burn in cartoon protest
BBC news:
Some people say that we should be tolerant of these Mohammedans, because any criticism risks alienating the moderate moslems who might be friendly to American values. I disagree. Our society depends on being able to publish political cartoons without fear of violence. If there are moderate moslems who agree, then I hope that they will distance themselves from the rioters.
George writes:
This article claims that about 40k European witches were burned between 1400 and 1800. I don't know about that, but no Christians today endorse that. Meanwhile, check out TheReligionOfPeace.com for facts about the Mohammedan Jihad today.
There are also some fake cartoons that the Mohammedans are circulating.
Syrians have set fire to the Norwegian and Danish embassies in Damascus to protest at the publication of newspaper cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.This just confirms the cartoons, and gives more evidence that there is a Mohammedan jihad against the civilized world.
Protesters stormed the Danish site amid chants of "God is great", before moving on to attack the Norwegian mission.
Some people say that we should be tolerant of these Mohammedans, because any criticism risks alienating the moderate moslems who might be friendly to American values. I disagree. Our society depends on being able to publish political cartoons without fear of violence. If there are moderate moslems who agree, then I hope that they will distance themselves from the rioters.
George writes:
What if a newspaper made fun of Jesus? You act like Islam is the only source of violence, but Christianity burned some witches at the stake in the Middle Ages.These analogies are silly. Making fun of Jesus is far more blasphemous than making fun of Muhammad, because Christians believe that Jesus was God. And yet NBC just aired a TV series called The Book Of Daniel that made fun of Jesus. No one rioted. They just didn't watch it, and the show was cancelled.
This article claims that about 40k European witches were burned between 1400 and 1800. I don't know about that, but no Christians today endorse that. Meanwhile, check out TheReligionOfPeace.com for facts about the Mohammedan Jihad today.
There are also some fake cartoons that the Mohammedans are circulating.
Mohammedan blasphemy
NY Times story:
It may be blasphemy to worship Muhammad as a god, but not to ridicule him.
Many Muslims consider it blasphemy to print any image of Muhammad, the founder of Islam, let alone a cartoon that ridicules him.I doubt that. If it is blasphemy, then how would the muslims even know what Muhammad looked like?
It may be blasphemy to worship Muhammad as a god, but not to ridicule him.
Friday, February 03, 2006
Brown v Yana
California Family law says:
So the parents have no rights in the matter. In this case, the boy ultimately got his way by refusing to board the plane!
7501. (a) A parent entitled to the custody of a child has a right to change the residence of the child, subject to the power of the court to restrain a removal that would prejudice the rights or welfare of the child.I thought that this meant that a parent who shares legal custody is subject to a court hearing before moving the child away from the other parent. But the California supreme court just ruled in Brown v Yana:
(b) It is the intent of the Legislature to affirm the decision in In re Marriage of Burgess (1996) 13 Cal.4th 25, and to declare that ruling to be the public policy and law of this state.
Thus, while sections 3006 and 3007 recognize the general right of a parent with sole custody to supervise and make decisions regarding a child's residence and education, section 7501, fairly read, contemplates that even a parent with sole legal and sole physical custody may be restrained from changing a child's residence, if a court determines the change would be detrimental to the child's rights or welfare.Furthermore, it ruled that the noncustodial parent has no right to a hearing.
Not only does section 7501 undermine any notion of a custodial parent's absolute right to relocate with a child, but so does the lack of any California decision supporting such a proposition.
So the parents have no rights in the matter. In this case, the boy ultimately got his way by refusing to board the plane!
Wednesday, February 01, 2006
NYC banning whole milk
NY news:
But children today are fat, or at least too many of them are, and to cut the risks of obesity, diabetes and other health problems, New York City -- the nation's largest school district -- has decided to cut whole milk from the menu. ...This is more proof that a lot of people have kooky ideas about nutrition. My local school only serves 1% milk. Claiming that chocolate skim milk is healthier for kids than whole milk is a little strange.
One percent and skim milk, though historically less popular, will still be served, and, to the great relief of many young palates, chocolate skim milk will remain an option in most schools, ...
Addicted to oil
John writes:
SOTU headline: Bush says Americans are "addicted to oil" -- which is like saying Americans are addicted to economic growth. (transcipt)Maybe he wants to distance himself from the oil industry, or to promote nuclear power.
On the one hand Bush takes credit for promoting economic growth. OTOH, he disparages oil consumption, which is the inevitable byproduct of that growth.
Complaining that we import oil from "unstable parts of the world," Bush set a goal by 2025 of replacing 75 percent of U.S. oil imports from the Middle East.
This is strange in a speech that also warned against the "false comfort of isolationism" ("In a complex and challenging time, the road of isolationism and protectionism may seem broad and inviting, yet it ends in danger and decline")
Wouldn't it be "isolationism and protectionism" to replace cheaper imported oil with higher-priced domestic energy? Of course it is.
If the U.S. reduced or even eliminated oil imports from the Middle East, that would accomplish nothing so long as our trading partners (Europe, Japan and China) continued to buy their oil from the Middle East, as they surely would.
Can anyone explain this incoherent nonsense about oil, coming from Bush and Cheney who supposedly represent the oil industry?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
