Thursday, October 17, 2002

John sends this National Review article about an Oregon assisted suicide court case. I have to agree that calling it a states rights case is misleading. It is about whether it is lawful for the federal DEA to be licensing physicians to dispense narcotics for the purpose of killing people. Seems like a bad idea to me, even if assisted suicide is a good idea.
Idea to improve patents. I think that patents should have a Disclaims section, as well as a Claims section. The idea is that the claims are supposed to define what the patent covers, but a series of Federal Circuit court decisions over the last 10 years has undermined that. Now, to really understand what a patent covers, you have to get the entire file history for $300, and try to decipher the confusing record. It is nearly impossible because the court decisions are confusing and contradictory, and not even the examiner and the inventor at the time necessarily knew what they were disclaiming. If the examiner were to approve a Disclaims section at the time the patent issues, then maybe it would make looking at the file history irrelevant.
John sends this story followup:
Charges dropped against woman whose kids were sunburned

Steubenville, Ohio-AP -- Prosecutors have dropped all charges against a woman who was jailed for eight days after her children were sunburned at a county fair in Ohio.
Eve Hibbits was originally charged with three counts of felony child endangerment -- but those charges were later reduced to a misdemeanor and she was released from jail.
Her attorney says prosecutors went to court last week to have the charges dropped.
A prosecutor says Hibbits is cooperating with children's services workers.
A sheriff's deputy arrested her in August after noticing her two-year-old girl and twin ten-month-old boys had severely sunburned faces at the fair.


Some people would say that cooler heads prevailed and justice was done, but I am still outraged. Getting a sunburn from a day at the fair is not evidence of a felony. The mom spent 8 days in jail. The prosecutors probably knew all along that they'd never get a jury to convict her of a felony, so they punished her as much as they could without convicting her of anything. Note the statement about "cooperating". That is a euphemism for "we told her that if she wants her kids back, she'd have to agree to submit indefinitely to the dictates of some 22-year-old childless social worker". That way the authorities can punish the poor mom without ever proving anything in court. And they can rationalize it to the media by saying that she is voluntarily cooperating.

Wednesday, October 16, 2002

Astronomers report that a black hole is at the center of our Milky Way galaxy. It had been suspected for some time.

Tuesday, October 15, 2002

Some environmentalists want to restore the Hetch Hetchy valley in Yosemite park. San Francisco wants to spend a couple of billion dollars improving the water resevoir. Usually, the SF politicians pretend that they are environmentalists.
Utah has an innumerate health inspector:
The menu at the Coffee Garden at 900 East and 900 South in Salt Lake City has included a scrumptious selection of quiche for about 10 years.
The recipe calls for four fresh eggs for each quiche.
A Salt Lake County Health Department inspector paid a visit recently and pointed out that research by the Food and Drug Administration indicates that one in four eggs carries salmonella bacterium, so restaurants should never use more than three eggs when preparing quiche.
The manager on duty wondered aloud if simply throwing out three eggs from each dozen and using the remaining nine in four-egg-quiches would serve the same purpose.
The inspector wasn't sure, but she said she would research it.

I didn't know that we still had piracy on the high seas. This book says that there is still a lot of piracy.
Liza writes:

Any of you who think that Muslim terrorists will settle down once the U.S. stops supporting Israel should explain to me why Al-Qaeda just bombed hundreds of tourists in Bali, most of whom were not Americans. Australia suffered the most casualties.

This is a religious war - fanatical Muslims around the world against Christians and Jews. It is not just a question of Muslims resenting and attacking Israelis and Americans. The fanatical Muslims are equally vile in persecuting indigenous Christians in their homelands, some of which are far from the Mideast.

The only way to cow them is to use overwhelming force with Western technology, which they cannot duplicate. The logical next step after our success in Afghanistan is Iraq. Yes, it is expensive, but we have to do it or we will be sitting ducks for a lot more attacks.


John responds:
"This is a religious war" - Why does that sound familiar? Oh, yes: Pat Buchanan's address to the Republican Convention, Houston, August 17, 1992. The speech that his enemies in both parties said was responsible for Bush I losing to Clinton.

Liza says Bali proves that "The logical next step after our success in Afghanistan is Iraq." What an awesome non sequitur! If our "success in Afghanistan" did not prevent Bali, what reason to suppose that bombing Baghdad would prevent similar attacks?

I would draw a different lesson from the Bali bombing: That our U.S. style of warfare is powerless to defeat the enemy we face. See this column.


Liza responds:

So what would you do, John? Give up and let them go on attacking Americans and other Westerners?

The attack on the French tanker is more evidence that the jihad is not just directed against the U.S. and Israel. France has been anti-Israel and pro-Iraq for a long time.

Al Qaeda has been getting state sponsorship from a few countries such as Iraq. Without the state sponsorship, they would not be able to train, organize and equip. Kicking out the sponsoring regimes one by one will send a message to the remaining ones.

What religious war was Pat Buchanan talking about? Surely not the Muslim one? Perhaps the domestic policy split between devout Christians and almost everyone else?


John responds:
I never said this is only about Israel. That would be too simple. Israel is merely one front in a wider conflict.

Actually, we don't know that al Qaeda has been getting state sponsorship from Iraq. As Charlie Rangel quipped, "there's more al Qaeda in Buffalo than Baghdad" (referring to the recent arrests of 6 Yemeni-Americans)

We have already destroyed al Qaeda's principal state sponsor. It is not clear that there is any other state sponsor. Al Qaeda draws varying amounts of support from a number of states; probably a dozen states give al Qaeda more support than Iraq does.

Yes of course; but my point is that for the last 10 years Buchanan was demonized for declaring that "there is a religious war" - the same declaration you are now making.

If this is a religious war, why attack Iraq, the most secular Muslim country except Turkey?

Bush, meanwhile, has repeatedly denied that religion has anything to do with the war he has declared. He says Islam is a religion of peace.

How can we fight and win a religious war if our leaders deny it?

Americans don't know how to fight a religious war. If we did, surely Step One would be to enforce a clear boundary separating us from all the heathens, pagans, gentiles, and barbarians. Exclude them, deport them, keep them out.

Evidently, our leaders are unable or unwilling to take those simple first steps. Instead, we are constantly lectured that "diversity" is strength.

If this is a religious war, I fear that the advantage belongs to the side with the stronger religious belief.

Liza suggests we should "cow them" (Muslim fanatics) by using "overwhelming force with Western technology, which they cannot duplicate." But that strategy has been attempted for many years by Israel, without success.

Monday, October 14, 2002

Amusing Microsoft controversy. A Msft ad about a woman switching from a Macintosh turned out turned out to use a stock photo for sale on the web. Here's the AP story, with links to the pictures.
Andy writes:
Roger, John and Liza all reject the logical similarity between the limited times of the Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP) and copyright duration. That analogy would have been useful in rebutting the claim that any fixed duration is limited, and could have given Breyer a basis for striking the 1998 Act without striking the 1976 Act.

Roger says "Why should shortening a copyright cause any more chaos than extending a copyright?" The answer is because the former disrupts millions of contracts and settled expectations, while the latter does not.

John says a copyright "could be 500 years or even perpetual without violating the RAP." A 500 year copyright or even a life-plus-70-years copyright does violate the principle underlying the RAP, which has been my point. The reason is because it frustrates alienability in the later years, as a practical matter, the same problem that the RAP addresses in common law. We mentioned this point obliquely in our brief, describing how difficult it is to bargain with heirs of a "life plus 70 years" copyright near the end of that long term.

Neither Roger nor John give any yardstick for ascertaining the "limited times" of copyright. RAP, applicable at the drafting of the Constitution, gives this context.

Liza says "The Rule Against Perpetuities has no bearing on the present property interest created by copyright."

I'm drawing an analogy, not applying RAP directly to copyright.

We all missed the rebuttal to Congress' argument that any fixed time, even 500 years, is still "limited" under the Copyright Clause. The rebuttal is that "limited" should be comparable to the limited right to render property inalienable, typically no more than life plus 50 years. The reason for these limits on property is identical: preserving alienability and use by others are necessary to efficiency and progress.


It is not true that copyright shortening is more disruptive than copyright extension. The disruption is the same either way. When the copyright on Gone With The Wind was about to expire, the copyright holders made decisions based on that expiration, such as licensing sequels. Others invested in unlicensed sequels and parodies, to be released after expiration. Copyright extension disrupted all of those contracts and expectations.

It is annoying that Breyer would base his reasoning on the hypothesis that copyright shortening would be chaotic. There is no evidence on the record of shortening causing any disruptions. If he were honest, he'd want to remand for some fact-finding on the issue. But that won't happen. Maybe we should have explicitly addressed the argument.

The RAP argument might have been worth a parenthetical remark, but that's all.

Liza writes:
Andy, I don't understand yoiur argument about alienability at all. A long-term copyright is alienable the entire time. While the market for selling it may dwindle in the later years (because the royalties presumably dwindle and will be cut off at the end of the term), there is certainly a right to sell or assign it.

A lease can be for 99 years or 999 years without violating the Rule against Perpetuities. The Rule applies only to unvested future interests. A 95-year copyright is vested from day one.


Liza is not completely correct. Some of the rights are not alienable. Under 17 USC 106A, authors have rights to attribution and integrity that cannot be alienated. Furthermore, under 17 USC 203, even if the author has sold all his rights, he can still recover most of them after 35 years.

Andy writes:
Roger's examples of the inalienability of copyright are fascinating. They do constitute contingent future interests, the kind the RAP was worried about. But that wasn't what I was talking about.

Property becomes inalienable when the transaction costs for sale or licensing exceed the value. For copyright, this occurs as the number of owners increase. After the life of the creator, inalienability of copyright increases. By 60 years after life, inalienability dominates.

Liza wrote, "A lease can be for 99 years or 999 years without violating the Rule against Perpetuities."
Yes, because a 999 year lease does not render the property inalienable. A 999 year copyright would.

I'm still curious if Roger, Liza or John feel a 500 year copyright would violate "limited Times," and if so, why? Alienability and RAP provide a reason.

I tossed Human Events right in the garbage this week. It's lost its way. I wouldn't recommend it anymore. What finally pushed me over the edge is its bashing of Senator Bob Smith of NH on p. 2.


What bashing? It said that some voters wanted to write in Smith, but that Smith was supporting Sununu, the primary winner.
The C++ language is being ruined. I don't know what it is about C++ that encourages people to make things a whole lot more complicated than necessary. A good example is the latest addition to the Boost library. These are functions that the C++ community usually thinks should be added to the language. There is a Boost date/time library that has over 60 include files! If you just want the current time, it is extremely complicated. It also throw exceptions! So you need some tricky and unnecessary exception handling logic to do anything with dates.

The 1998 C++ standard has a new keyword called export. Apparently the idea was to make it possible to declare a template in a header file without giving the full definition. Unfortunately that is impossible, so any compiler that sees such a declaration has to find the template source code, whereever it is, and use that source whenever the template is instantiated. So the export keyword is completely useless. None of the major compiler vendors support it.
Judge Jackson finally defends himself for speaking to the press about the Microsoft case. The real problem is that the DC Circuit did not want publicity because it massively botched the case. Microsoft violated antitrust law, and violated its consent agreement, but it is not going to suffer any punishment because of horrible DC Circuit decisions. I'm glad that Jackson talked to the press about the case, because it gave the public an inside view of the case. We need more scrutiny of the courts, not less. I think that all federal court and appellate proceedings should be open to TV cameras.
John writes:
While everyone was focused on the famous case of U.S. v. Emerson (5th
Cir., Oct. 16, 2001), cert. denied (June 10, 2002)
Did anyone know that the Supreme Court has granted cert in anotherpotential Second Amendment case, U.S. v. Bean, also from Texas, also from the 5th Circuit?
Oral argument is Wednesday, Oct. 16. Briefs are posted here.


There is a direct split in the circuits, so the SC has to hear it. Under federal law, a felon loses his gun rights but can apply to the ATF to reinstate them, and appeal to the courts if rejected. The ATF refused to consider his application, but Congress didn't fund it. The case may not involve the 2A, and might just be an interpretation of the intent of Congress in the face of conflicting laws.

Sunday, October 13, 2002

Andy writes:
Roger says the punitive judgment against Philip Morris is unreasonable. Yes, I'd agree, but that doesn't make it unconstitutional. State legislatures define what's legal and what isn't, and Fortune 500 companies can fend for themselves there. Courts shouldn't bail them out for refusing to back conservatives.

Roger claims "You need Fourier transforms to understand the uncertainty principle."
Hardly. From Roger's own link, the principle simply means "the better position is known, the less well the momentum is known (and vice versa)." Quantification adds little to this insight.

Re: the Coase theorem, Roger writes "It is just an observation."
Yes, like all of math and science.

In the Eldred v. Ashcroft copyright case, we all missed an argument that the copyright extension essentially creates inalienable interests contrary to the Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP), the Framers' intent, and Coase. The new copyright period is life of the creator plus 70 years. Assuming 30-year differences in generation, that leaves scattered grandchildren and great-grandchildren controlling the copyright, ultimately making it inalienable (if unsold until the end).

The RAP requires alienability within 21 years of the death of children, which in actuary terms would be about the life-plus-50 year period of the 1976 Act. The RAP does not require alienation, of course, but property taxes do. Copyright, lacking such taxes, creates practically inalienable property near the end of its term, and should not go beyond the RAP equivalent of life plus 50. This argument would have given the Court a way to differentiate the 1998 Act from the 1976 Act.

Though I could find nothing published on this, Coase reinforces the brilliance of the RAP in economic terms. Yet some states are quietly repealing RAP.

FYI, one scholar commented that the American revolution changed the view of property here from a political construct to a legal one. Anyone familiar with that? I suppose the Constitution does have strong clauses prohibiting government interference with property which were lacking before.


In QM, the wave function of a particle can be expressed as a function of position or as a function of momentum. One is the fourier transform of the other. Your statement of the uncertainty principle is just a crude statement of a property of fourier transforms. Theorems about fourier transforms give more precise quantitative info.

Andy cites the uncertainty principle as a example of a non-quantitative breakthrough. In fact, it is quite quantitative. As quantitative as any other breakthru I know. Does he think that a fourier transform is not quantitative?

In math and science, it usually takes a little more than an observation to win a prize. Mathematicians consider Nash's Nobel-prizewinning work to be his most trivial work.

So Andy would be hoping the US SC would find that the Constitution's "limited times" coincides with the ancient RAP limits? I doubt that would get any votes.

I guess the problem is that we need Breyer's vote, and Breyer thinks that invalidating the 1976 term extension would cause chaos. Breyer is nuts. Why should shortening a copyright cause any more chaos than extending a copyright? It is possible that contracts are written based on the expected life of the copyright, and that if a party misjudged the term, then he might have made a contract concession that he didn't need to make, and thereby lose money. But that can happen whether copyrights are made shorter or longer. No difference.

Perhaps Breyer was referring to the possibility that those who have been paying royalties on old works might suddenly demand their money back for what they paid since 1976. Yes, that might be chaos. But that would never happen anyway. Those people could have contested the 1976 law, and chose not to. There are statutes of limitations on contesting contracts. The SC would probably not invalidate the copyrights retroactively, but I don't think it would make much difference if they did.
Andy writes:
I haven't heard from John or Roger on the issue of punitive damages and the Constitution. A case is before the Supreme Court on that issue. Justice Thomas says there is no constitutional limit on punitive damages, and I agree. It's a matter of state law. Time for large corporations to start supporting conservative legislators, or be sacrificed by liberal attorneys.

The reality, of course, is that feminists dominate the politics of large corporations. Fortune magazine reflects this in its articles, which cater to the politics of corporate ad departments.

Roger says that Nash's Nobel prize had an even longer delay than Coase's, which was 31 years. Except Nash only received 1/3rd of a Nobel Prize, and I believe a key element of that Prize was less than 31 years from its award. But it's hard for me to tell, which says something about the award.

Many Nobel prizes have a liberal gloss, and Nash's is no exception. One or both of his co-winners worked on a nuclear disarmament project.

As to Kelvin's bias towards quantification, the greatest 20th century breakthroughs have been otherwise. The uncertainty principle, Godel's theorem and Coase's work all lack quantification. Kelvin, by the way, was a Creationist who lived long after fellow Brit Darwin proposed his theory.


I certainly do not think that it is reasonable that Philip Morris should pay $28B in punitive damages. I don't even agree that Betty Bullock should get any compensatory damages. Rarely do punitive damages make any sense. They should be abolished, or capped by statute, or made very difficult to get.

But what is the federal issue? Congress regulates tobacco, and PM followed regulations. Is the theory that runaway juries are a threat to interstate commerce? I think a $28B judgment is a threat.

Nash's work was 40+ years previous. I don't know about the co-winners.

See the Carter announcement? Amazing arrogance from a group that gave a peace prize to Arafat.

Huhh? You need Fourier transforms to understand the uncertainty principle. Eg, see this or this.

Goedel's theorem is based entirely on a quantification of proof theory.

Here is one statement of Coase's theorem: The initial allocation of legal entitlements does not matter from an efficiency perspective so long as they can be exchanged in a perfectly competitive market.

I guess I'll agree that there isn't much quantitive info here. It is just an observation.
InstaPundit points out how the gun control crowd makes contradictory arguments:
"Saturday Night Specials" (cheap handguns) = Bad, must be banned
"Military Style Handguns" (expensive handguns) = Bad, must be banned
"Assault Weapons" (inaccurate, short-range rifles) = Bad, must be banned
"Sniper Rifles" (accurate, long-range rifles) = Bad, must be banned

Update: Glenn asked the rhetorical question about tracing shell casings, "what are you going to do, put a barcode on them?" A few hours later, the NY Times published a story about a couple of inventors who got US Patent 6,462,302 for making gun barrels that put a bar code on the bullet as it is shot. The NY Times has a weekly column about patents that do not necessarily have any commercial value. It doesn't sound very practical to me.
One good byproduct of the war on terrorism is that it has derailed the Bush-Fox "migration agenda". The NY Times reports:
"It is very clear to me that [Mexican] President Fox understands he is not going to achieve much of his migration agenda in the next few years," said Sergio Sarmiento, a political columnist in Mexico City. ...
Mr. Bush said on Sept. 5, 2001, that "the United States has no more important relationship in the world than our relationship with Mexico." ...
Before the attacks, Mr. Fox had seized upon Mexico's enhanced status to push a migration project that was as ambitious as the North American Free Trade Agreement. Declaring himself president to 100 million Mexicans at home and 23 million in the United States, he challenged Washington to expand permanent visas and guest-worker programs for Mexicans, and to give legal status to about 3 million Mexican migrants.

John sends this latest Microsoft bug that allows a malicious person to take over your Windows computer. It was Microsoft's 58th security advisory this year. Here is a Microsoft flack, trying to put positive spin on the situation:
"Outlook Express ships with every Windows system, or rather as part of IE, so it's on every system. But unless it is configured to receive mail, you are not at risk," said Scott Culp, manager for Microsoft security response.

Saturday, October 12, 2002

Joe writes:
Walter Williams is just not a Nobel-level guy. He wrote a good book, "The State Against Blacks." If you listen to him on Rush, he's really a Johnny-one note. Sowell probably should be a winner, but he has done virtually no quantitative work, and the judges seem to like that stuff.

"When you can measure what you are speaking about, and express it in numbers, you know something about it; but when you cannot measure it, when you cannot express it in numbers, your knowledge is of a meager and unsatisfactory kind: it may be the beginning of knowledge, but you have scarcely, in your thoughts, advanced to the stage of science." Lord Kelvin, Popular Lectures and Addresses (1891-1894)

Joe writes: "True, true , true. Let's see - was he the guy who said heavier than air vehicles would never fly?"
Andy (who ghost-wrote an Eldred amicus petition) writes:

Volokh's prediction and reasoning for a 6-3 win by Eldred are intriguing.

Like me, Volokh predicts Thomas, Scalia, Souter and Stevens will rule for Eldred, and Rehnquist and Ginsburg will rule for the Bush Administration. And maybe those are the 4 pro-Eldred votes to get him cert. (it only requires 4, not 5, votes for cert.).

But I disagree with Volokh about Kennedy and O'Connor, who I think will side with Congress and the Bush Administration. Kennedy, after all, hopes to be elevated to Chief Justice in 9 months when Rehnquist presumably resigns. So Eldred needs Breyer to win, I think.

Roger writes, "Laffer is a joke. He hasn't accomplished anything."

Just the greatest economic insight of the last 25 years: that lowering taxes increases government revenue, also called Supply Side economics.


I am sure that there is plenty of literature on optimal levels of taxation. What has Laffer contributed to it? Did he ever prove that tax levels were so high that lowering taxes would increase revenue? Where is that paper? Where is the proof? Laffer was all talk, no substance.
The US Patent Office has been issuing a lot of bad patents. Most of the weird ones are from crackpot inventors, but even IBM does kooky patents. Check out US Patent 6,329,919, issued Dec. 2001, for using restrooms on a first-come, first-served basis. It claims:
What is claimed is:
1. A method of providing reservations for restroom use, comprising: receiving a reservation request from a user; and notifying the user when the restroom is available for his or her use.

There are 4 inventors, and 64 claims. It also claims letting airline passengers use the restroom in the order of ticket price, so first class passengers could use it first.

Friday, October 11, 2002

No one should take the Nobel Peace Prize seriously, after Yassir Arafat won in 1994. Or maybe after Henry Kissinger won in 1973. Here is a good National Review column explaining why Jimmy Carter does not deserve the peace prize.
Washington Uinversity (St. Louis) refuses to let law students form a pro-life organization. The excuse: they don't oppose the death penalty! This is more evidence of intolerant left-wingers on campus.
NY Times has an article and editorial favorable to the Supreme Court rejecting copyright extension.

Here are 2 lame arguments defending copyright extension:
Olson gained ground when he invoked another clause of the Constitution, the "necessary and proper" clause, as a justification for the legislation as a matter of equity.

The court, [Olsen] said, should not say that 99 years is too long for a copyright to exist, noting that the works of Herman Melville and Franz Schubert ''weren't valued until many years after their deaths.''


No one could really think that anything is necessary about copyright law. If that argument were valid, it would justify any federal law.

The Melville argument is sillier. Melville died at age 72 in 1891. The NY Times obituary said, "forty years ago the appearance of a new book by Herman Melville was esteemed a literary event, not only throughout his own country, but so far as the English-speaking race extended. ... Years ago the books by which Melville's reputation had been made had long been out of print and out of demand. " His last novel was publish in 1857. Moby Dick was 1851. Apparently his novels were highly regarded when they came out, but the market only existed for a few years. A copyright of 10 years might have been as useful to him as a copyright of 50 years.

But under copyright extension, Melville's novel would still be copyrighted until 1961. Giving some publisher a monopoly in 1960 over Moby Dick would not have gotten Melville to write any more novels.

Andy writes:
Based on oral argument reports and the written reports, I conclude that the liberal Justices took to Lessig more than Rehnquist and O'Connor did. Maybe we have the Bajakajian situation, whereby Thomas joined Stevens, Souter, Ginsburg and Breyer to apply the Excessive Fines against the government and force it to return $357,144 to someone who merely had failed to report it. We could still win by trading Ginsburg for Scalia. But if Thomas holds against Eldred, Lessig's lost. Too bad Lessig didn't work harder to appeal to Thomas. Well, we did.

I don't know that Friedman is really a conservative. He opposed California's Proposition 13, for example. Libertarian might be a better label for Friedman.

The conservative economists are Thomas Sowell, Walter Williams and Arthur Laffer. There should be at least one Nobel Prize among them, but that hasn't happened and isn't likely to. Liberals don't like giving awards, particularly academic ones, to conservatives.

Economic theory for copyright seems badly underdeveloped. Easterbrook wrote a superficial piece and seemed to imply that he favors clear rules, by which he may mean strong copyrights on which the market can bargain. But that only works if you ignore the monopoly inherent in strong copyrights. I think he once sided with the dental association's control of its codes.


Volokh has a detailed prediction of a 6-3 in favor of ruling the extension unconstitutional.
Andy writes:
Joe wrote, "Chicago economists have dominated for the last 10-15 years." Interesting point, which led me to do some research.

Only established in 1969 and funded by the Swedish Federal Reserve (not Nobel), the Economics "Nobel" Prize has had a huge pro-quantitative bias. The publicized award to mathematician John Nash is a case in point. Did he ever even study or write about economics? )I'd question the movie's portrayal of him thinking about Adam Smith in the bar when he had his insight.)

Chicago likes the quantification approach and thus has done well with this prize. But I haven't heard of any of the prize-winners, except arguably Friedman (1976 winner), being conservative. Most of them tend to be utilitarian liberals, like Posner.

That's not to knock Chicago, though. Coase, an Englishman, did his great work there, and he ultimately did win an unshared Nobel Prize after an inordinate delay of 31 years. Judge Easterbrook, one of the best appellate judges in the country, came out of Chicago. So did Talent and Ashbrook.

Thursday, October 10, 2002

Did Congress declare war today? I'm not sure. I just read press reports. It sounds like Congress really authorized the president to declare war. The Constitution says Congress has the power to declare war, and I don't think that Congress can delegate the power. But maybe the Congress just authorized the president to take emergency defensive measures. If so, the president has those powers anyway.

Wednesday, October 09, 2002

Bad day for free speech. It looks like oral arguments on copyright extension went badly for Lessig, according to NY Times, AP, LawMeme, and Kwin and more NY Times.

It sounded like Breyer was looking for a way to declare the 1998 law unconstitutional without touching the 1976 law, but Lessig could not give him any such rationale.

John writes:
Breyer's question was logical and foreseeable. However, I can think of no better answer than the one Lessig gave (according to Nina Totenberg's report on NPR/ATC): Yes, logic implies that if the 20-year extension passed in 1998 was unconstitutional, the earlier 20-year extension passed in 1976 was also unconstitutional, but there is ample precedent for the Supreme Court to make its decision prospective only and not retroactive.


The question is logical and foreseeable, but also stupid. The court only has to rule on the question before it, not hypotheticals about other laws. When someone brings a case that a punishment is cruel and unusual, the court rules on the issue without ever defining precisely which punishments are lawful and which are not. No one challenged the 1976 law.

The main purpose of the 1976 law was to remove the copyright notice requirement, and to move into conformance with the Berne convention. Maybe no one wised up to the fact that Congress had decided to pass a 20-year extension every 20 years. The 1998 law was more clearly an attempt to make copyrights perpetual.

Breyer's argument can just as easily be run the other way. He is saying, if the 1998 law is unconstitutional, then why isn't the 1976 law unconstitutional? He could just as easily ask, if the 1998 is constitutional, then does that automatically make extensions in 2018, 2038, 2058, etc. constitutional? If so, he just approved a perpetual copyright.

John writes:
Those are good, snappy answers. Too bad Lessig, apparently, wasn't prepared with a similar response to what now seems like an obvious objection.
Just because Breyer's question was obvious doesn't make it "stupid." The issue of whether a Supreme Court decision is retroactive has come up many times before. An experienced advocate would have been able to handle it.
Probably our best hope is simply the fact that the Court took the case. Why would they take it unless some justices, at least, were interested in overturning it? There was no split among the Circuits that needed to be settled.


Andy writes:

Good analyses by Roger and John, plus John's superb links. The internet sure is powerful. One link said that only those who were in the public line prior to 3 am actually got in!

Ginsburg didn't like the Free Speech argument, which is predictable because I think her husband practiced in copyright law for decades. But that doesn't mean Thomas won't like the Free Speech argument, and if he runs with its power than that it will influence the outcome.

Consistency in outcome with the 1976 Act is an issue, but I doubt that will be dispositive. Consistency, after all, is the hobglobin of little minds.

However, it does sound like Lessig stumbled as badly at oral argument as in his brief on his "balancing", good-government approach. From one observer: "Stevens asked whether a retrospective extension that does promote progress is permissible. Lessig said yes [N.B.: that admission loses the case]. Stevens then said that the 1998 law, at least on its face, does that. Lessig: well, that's the government's position. Stevens: but that's what you just said. Lessig: no, Congress still has to abide by the constitutional limits. We were all confused." Confused indeed. Lessig loses if the Court accepts his admissions.

Our brief strived to pick up Rehnquist et al. on the "limited government" approach of Lopez. A very astute observer saw this today. That observer wondered if "the court was interested in extending the precedent set in Lopez, which for the first time in many years constrained Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce. Some have thought that this issue would be raised by analogy from the commerce clause to the copyright clause. The Chief Justice is the only one who raised the issue in a single question to Prof. Lessig. The question was oblique, and only implied the question, but Prof. Lessig recognized it and provided the appropriate answer, which seemed to please the Chief Justice. It was not raised by any other justice, nor was the Solicitor General provided a similar question."

If Rehnquist bites on our Lopez argument, and Thomas bites on our Free Speech argument, then we probably win by adding Scalia, Breyer and Stevens or Souter or Kennedy. We could even lose Rehnquist and still win. But if Lessig's admissions like the one above stick, then we lose.


I agree with Andy that Lessig should have told Stevens that a retrospective copyright extension cannot promote progress because it cannot provide an incentive for the author.

Andy writes:
Roger's excellent blog has a link to a NY Times article, which made this observation:
Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist seemed unsympathetic to those who want the law overturned. "You want the right to copy people's works verbatim,'' he told Eldred's lawyer.
My reaction: unfortunately, this may also be the result of Lessig's liberal approach to the case. Lessig argues for public rights and common good. Lessig thinks private property rights should be balanced against the "commons". He proposes new balancing tests for copying of others works.
Apparently Rehnquist didn't think much of this approach, and neither do I. The only way the case can be won is to embrace private property, but that the government entitlement must be limited. Lessig's talk about the commons hurts our cause.


What is wrong with Lessig's answer:
Professor Lessig replied, "We want the right to copy verbatim works that should be in the public domain and would be in the public domain but for a statute that cannot be justified" either under the First Amendment or Congress's copyright power.


We absolutely do want to right to copy verbatim works that are in the public domain.

Andy writes:
Professor Lessig replied, "We want the right to copy verbatim works that should be in the public domain and would be in the public domain but for a statute that cannot be justified" either under the First Amendment or Congress's copyright power.
Roger wrote: "We absolutely do want to right to copy verbatim works that are in the public domain."

The flaw in Lessig's answer is that it inflames, rather than ameliorates, Rehnquist's concern about Lessig's assault on private property. Lessig argues that works should be in the public domain for the good of the "commons". His reasoning is anti-private property, and my guess is that Rehnquist will rule against him for that reason.

If Lessig were conservative, then he would have replied: "We do NOT support a right to copy verbatim the property of another. But as the Framers made clear, Congress has sharply limited powers to grant copyright entitlements. Protections other than copyright, such as trademark or licenses, can extend beyond the copyright entitlement to prevent copying."

Roger wrote, "Meanwhile, here is this year's Nobel tally:
Physics: USA, USA, Japan
Chemistry: USA, Japan, Swiss
Medicine: UK, UK, USA
Economics: USA, USA
Literature: Hungary
So US 6, Europe 4, Japan 2.
Sounds about right. US intellectual output is about the same as the rest of the world put together."

Non sequitur. The Nobel prize is a grant by liberals to liberals. How'd we do with the MacArthur prize this year? Same dynamic.

Conservatives would do well to criticize these prizes more. Brace yourself for the Nobel Peace prize, to be awarded tomorrow.


Update: here is Lessig's account of the hearing.
Brain Size Tied to Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. A new study found that the brains of children and adolescents in whom attention deficit hyperactivity disorder is diagnosed are on average 3 percent to 4 percent smaller in volume than those of children without the condition. There were no controls for race or IQ. Maybe lower IQ kids have smaller brains, and then low grades cause them to get misdiagnosed as having ADHD.
Update: Apparently there were some controls for IQ. A vocabulary test was used as a proxy for IQ.
Mark wrote, in connection to biology prof Dini who refuses to recommend creationists:
If a student said (and demonstrated), "I have excellent knowledge of all the subject matter, but I'll be damned if I ever consider it in my future work," would you recommend him?


Not sure if you mean "I'll be damned" in the technical theological sense rather than the more commonly heard colloquial "ain't gonna do that" sense. Either way, it is a bizarre straw man. To make it a little more relevant to medicine, what if the student said, "I'll be damned if I ever prescribe Prozac."? I'd be curious about the reasons for the statement, but I wouldn't blackball the student for it.

Nowhere in science have I found such narrow-minded, bigoted, and intolerant people as in evolutionary biology. Michael Dini and his defenders here on t.o are prime examples. Only an evolutionary biology would argue that the definition of science requires that alternate points of view be eradicated and undergraduates with those views be blackballed from higher education.
Andy claims that the media has covered up the new Miss America's promotion of abstinence. He says, "The media abhor abstinence. Profits in the media are 90% or more reliant on selling sex in one form or another." He cites this story:
The problems began the night of the pageant, when the pageant host announced that Miss Illinois' platform was on stopping teen violence, not the abstinence education platform with which Harold is identified throughout the state, the platform upon which she won the Miss Illinois title.


Now Miss America herself has spoken out. The Wash Times says:
Miss America 2003, Erika Harold, yesterday said pageant officials have ordered her not to talk publicly about sexual abstinence, a cause she has advocated to teenage girls in Illinois.
"Quite frankly, and I'm not going to be specific, there are pressures from some sides to not promote [abstinence]," the 22-year-old woman from Urbana, Ill., told The Washington Times.
In her first visit to Washington since winning the crown Sept. 21, Miss Harold resisted efforts by Miss America officials to silence her pro-chastity opinions.
"I will not be bullied," Miss Harold said yesterday at the National Press Club, as officials tried to prevent reporters from asking questions about her abstinence message.


The only previous news stories I found referencing her abstinence promotion were:

For Erika Harold, entrance into Harvard Law School will have to wait for one more year—until her reign as Miss America 2003 comes to a close. The conservative abstinence advocate claimed her crown with tears of joy and surprise at the Miss America Pageant on Saturday night. [Harvard student newspaper]

Before and up to winning the Miss Illinois title, she had promoted abstinence education for four years, working on behalf of Project Reality in Chicago. After she became Miss Illinois, the state program chose anti-violence and anti-bullying as her social-issue platform, deciding it was more pertinent, her father said. “Basically, she had to take on the new platform, which was also something she had a lot of passion for,” he said. “She will eventually integrate both issues, but in the beginning she'll have to promote the one issue and get it established.” [Champaign Illinois newspaper]

Andy writes:

John sent me this exchange from the AP about Eldred. I'm afraid Olson got the better of this exchange, and I bet Olson gets the better of Lessig today. The bottom line is that Lessig's argument that he disagrees with Congress, and that public good is being sacrificed, is doomed to failure. The only hope for success is that Thomas or Scalia picks up on the principles in our brief, which are ignored by Lessig.

From AP story:
Erik S. Jaffe, a Washington attorney who filed a friend-of-the-court brief, said Congress could keep extending the copyright protection forever, even though creators have been adequately paid for their inventions.

"It's like the last mortgage note is to be paid, and the bank says, 'No, you've got another 20 years,'" Jaffe said.

Solicitor General Theodore Olson told the court in a filing that Congress has been conservative with its extensions. He said "there is no basis for courts to second-guess Congress' determinations."

Tuesday, October 08, 2002

The British press reports:
Most MMR studies are meaningless, investigation claims
A massive review of the evidence on the safety of the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine has concluded that most studies to date have been meaningless, and that more research into the vaccine's long-term effects is needed. ...
The review's author, Dr Thomas Jefferson, criticised the lack of clear design and reporting criteria for vaccine safety studies and called urgently for guidelines.
'In most of the studies we assessed, it was almost impossible to ascertain what had actually been done,' he said. 'The results were certainly deficient. We don't know whether the research was too.'


The Journal of the AMA just published my letter criticizing a an article about vaccine web sites. I maintain some vaccine info links here.
The upcoming oral arguments before the US Supreme Court on copyright extension are getting a lot of publicity. See the good summary by McCullagh, who also has a link to an opposing view -- the Ayn Rand Institute thinks that those on the side of free speech are Marxist. Eagle Forum has a excellent amicus brief.
Franz Boas is finally debunked. More than anyone else, Boas was the leader in 20th century scientific thinking that there is no such thing as race. He was a socialist/communist anthropologist who was ideologically opposed to racial distinctions. In particular, he did widely cited research on craniometry which found skull measurements are the results of environmental influences, not race.

Stephen Jay Gould, a Harvard historian of science and evolution populist, was a follower of Boas. Gould's biggest selling book was a Boasian attack on craniometry called The Mismeasure Of Man.

Now the NY Times reports that the Boas research was bogus.
Dr. Jantz said that Boas "was intent on showing that the scientific racism of the day had no basis, but he did have to shade his data some to make it work that way."


Gould's work had been previously debunked, but he continued to enjoy high status among leftist academics. Politically incorrect essays on the subject may be found here and here. I don't know about these essays, but you can't trust the scientific establishment when they allow bogus work from Boas and Gould to go unchallenged.

Update: Here is the authors' abstract.
Bob writes, referring to the prof who only writes letters of recommendation for evolutionists: "The problem here is your refusal to distinguish a scientific question from an ideological question. The professor is asking a scientific question and is entitled to require a scientific answer."

He is not asking a scientific question. A scientific question might be: What is the evidence that human descended from other primates? Or: What causes antibiotic resistance? Instead he asks: "How do you think the human species originated?"

He is just baiting the student to mention religion. If the student mentions God, he can't goto medical school.

There is currently a lot of discussion of this issue on the usenet group talk.origins under the subjects, "Prof only recommends evolutionists for med school" and "Prof Won't Write Letter for Creationists". That group is dominated by dogmatic Darwinians who think that they are on some sort of mission to stamp out Creationism. The big majority of them thought that the prof was completely right to blackball the student from medical school! Anyone who is even suspected of Creationism is unfit for anything, in their view. Some of them are even college profs, and they imply that they do the same, but don't admit it on the web page.

As an evolutionist there said, this only confirms that the creationists are right about so many adherents of evolution, that so many are dogmatic and intolerant of belief. Prof. Michael Dini's Texas Tech web page is a smoking gun.

A curious thing about Dini is that he once joined a Catholic order, and years later dropped out. So it appears that either he harbors some sort of grudge against Christianity, or he has a Catholic theological disagreement with the Protestant Fundamentalists. Whether or not Dini is still a Catholic, he was a devout Catholic when he was in college. I wonder how he would have like some college prof calling him into his office, and being quizzed by some prof who controls your career and thinks that Catholic dogma is unacceptably unscientific.

Monday, October 07, 2002

Andy writes:
I'm starting to lose my enthusiasm for vouchers. It's curriculum that matters, not the teachers or school. Education isn't going to improve by shuffling kids among the same curricula. Instead, we get busing (recently in Chicago area), dumbing down tests, and an incentive for bilingual education (to exempt students from tests, as in Florida). Political benefit of vouchers is still good, though, so I wouldn't oppose them. I just don't see them as a clear winner anymore. I suppose breaking up the monopoly is good, and may have secondary benefits.

The idea behind vouchers is that more parent choice will pressure the schools to be more competitive, and hence better. But better in what sense? They should be better in the sense of better meeting the demands and expectations of the parents.

Some parents want different things. Maybe some want better teachers, some better sports, some better art classes, some better curriculum, etc. Vouchers just make the schools more accountable to parents. If what you want in a school is radically different from what everyone else wants in a school, then competition doesn't do you any good.

It is just like anything else in the market. If you like cheeseburgers like most people, then competition between burger joints will get you better, faster, tastier, cheaper cheeseburgers. If you are a vegetarian, then competition between burger joints doesn't do you any good.

Andy writes:
Vouchers don't bring competition in curricula, which is all that matters. Multiple products in a market don't guarantee real competition. You might say that it is better than having only one product in the market, but sometimes the improvement is insignificant. It's like moving deck chairs on the Titanic.


In grade school, there is some choice. The public, Montessori, Waldorf, Carden, and others have different philosophies and curricula.

Eg, Montessori emphasizes self-paced instruction. Waldorf says:
Some distinctive features of Waldorf education include the following: Academics are de-emphasized in the early years of schooling. There is no academic content in the Waldorf kindergarten experience (although there is a good deal of cultivation of pre-academic skills), and minimal academics in first grade. Reading is not taught until second or third grade, though the letters are introduced carefully in first and second. ... There are no "textbooks" as such in the first through fifth grades. All children have "main lesson books", which are their own workbooks which they fill in during the course of the year. They essentially produce their own "textbooks" which record their experiences and what they've learned.


Vouchers bring competition in curricula if there is demand for it. That is the way with any market-based solution. It only brings what people want.

In Calif, private schools can teach whatever curriculum they want, but most of them voluntarily take the same standardized test that is given to the public schools, and which is tied to the public school curriculum. So any school that deviates too much runs the risk that it might have to parents why the scores are below par.

John writes:
The empirical fact, however, is that competition among burger joints has not produced better, tastier burgers. It has merely produced a vast proliferation in the number of burger outlets, which differ only in the most superficial ways and make no pretense of competing on the quality of the product.

Contrary to Roger, I would suggest that the fast-food industry serves as a warning and object lesson, not a model, for school-choice enthusiasts.

Here we have what is seemingly one of America's most dynamic and competitive industries. It has blanketed the world with probably 100,000 retail outlets (McDonalds alone passed the 25,000 mark over a decade ago). But the quality of the product is basically the same as it was in the days of Ray Kroc - unfit for human consumption.

I admit I have not eaten a fast-food burger in 25 years or more, but I am certain that today's burgers are identical to the ones I was unable to eat 25 years ago.

The giant fast-food purveyors surely go through the motions of competing with each other, but the evidence refutes the idea that competition has brought "better ... tastier" meals. At McDonalds and its many so-called competitors, the only thing you taste are the MSG-spiked condiments with which your food is slathered.

Competition, indeed! Fewer Americans today than ever before in history have ever even tasted a decent burger made from fresh well-seasoned ground beef cooked to order, or french fries made from a real potato instead of frozen cardboard.

Conclusion: it takes more than competition to improve the schools.


My conclusion is that John is not in the target market for McDonalds. McDonalds keeps its customers happy, even if John doesn't like it.

Yes, it is likely to be the same with schools. What some people want in schools is not what others want.

John writes:
Roger still doesn't get it. I am in the market for fast food of decent quality. Because McDonalds is ubiquitous, nearly every day I pass by them looking for something fast and edible. If McDonalds decides they don't want me as a customer, what does that tell you about them? I am a prospective customer who is definitely not happy.

It is disturbing that a school choice advocate holds the fast food industry as a "likely" model for education. The purpose of education is not to give people what they "want"; that is the standard that has given us network TV, rap music, junk food, and casinos. The purpose of education is to improve and elevate what people want. It is to teach people to appreciate and value what they initially may not want.


When did John become such an elitist? You want to gubmnt to shut down commercial TV and replace it with Masterpiece Theatre reruns, so the people can be improved and elevated? You want to eat at gubmnt cafeterias and listen to the Air Force marching band?

My complaint with the public schools is not the quality, but the fact that policies are driven by what some bureaucrats think are good for the people, rather than what they really want.

Joe writes:
But the quality IS lousy. And it's not just a few bureaucrats who are imposing their ideas - it's a whole mindset that is remarkably similar everywhere (just look at all the colorful, PC, "there's no right answer"/every construction person shown is a woman) - a mindset that is defined by the whole agenda of liberal/left/union/environmentalist/feminist...... democrat ideas.


Andy writes:
I'm not opposed to aptitude tests. But I don't find them very meaningful. They don't assess motivation, inquisitiveness, independent thinking or creativity, all of which are more important than basic problem-solving or memory skills.

Joe replied, "That's the sort of stuff that liberals always say in order to discredit IQ tests. So you end up with all this fuzzy stuff that is designed to measure all these other 'types of intelligence.' Added to aptitude tests, OK. But they should not be a substitute."

White liberals have traditionally been big fans of aptitude tests, tracking, elite programs, etc. I don't hear them extolling motivation or independent thinking. Dissent is the last thing they want.

If you pick a group of students based on scores on aptitude tests and I pick a group of students based on motivation, inquisitiveness, independent thinking and creativity, which group do you think will accomplish more? Which group will produce more intellectual breakthroughs? I would say the latter. China has a higher national aptitude than the US, but we have more intellectual breakthroughs. And Europe has had more than us.

Priory is a fine school and I would probably send my son there. But my view is that the admissions officer is making a mistake in filling the school based on the best aptitude and grades of 5th graders.

The debate between John and Roger is somewhat moot, because under either view vouchers are not likely to make a significant difference. Vouchers are a cumbersome libertarian way of ducking the real issue: what and how children will be taught. That battle needs be to fought directly, not indirectly.

Sunday, October 06, 2002



Schlaflys in the news. Phyllis was on MSNBC/Donahue and is cited in Newsweek's Glitterati vs. Geeks. She is on the side of the Geeks in trying to limit copyrights in a current case before the US Supreme Court. Newsweek says, "Lessig knows that Eldred v. Ashcroft is the best chance to turn the tide in Silicon Valley’s war against Hollywood—a conflict where Hollywood has won every round so far."

Andy is helping AAPS defend Medicare physicians from vindictive prosecutions.

Ellen is a big college field hockey and lacrosse star. That's her picture on the right.

Gumma asks me to point out the difference between Eagle Forum's position on copyright extension, and Lessig's. Eagle Forum argued that the copyright clause in the US Constitution says:
To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;

and Congressional copyright laws should promote progress. There was an earlier DC Circuit decision (called Schnapper) that held that "Congress need not 'require that each copyrighted work be shown to promote the useful arts.' " Eagle Forum adopted a narrow reading of that decision, and persuaded one judge on the 3-judge DC Circuit panel. In other words, the laws enabling copyrights have to promote progress, but not every single copyrighted work has to promote progress.

Lessig was supposed to be on the same side, but he expressly acknowledged "that the preamble of the Copyright Clause is not a substantive limit on Congress' legislative power." At oral argument, he was given a second chance to support the Eagle Forum brief, but he refused. The final DC Circuit opinion was 2-1 in favor of upholding copyright extension, with one judge agreeing with Eagle Forum and two judges refusing to address the issue because Eldred's main attorney, Lessig, had disavowed the argument. Lessig ended up not convincing anyone of anything. Let's hope he does better in oral argument before the US Supreme Court this week. He claims to now support the Eagle Forum position.

You can support the geeks and get a free bumper sticker: FREE THE MOUSE.

Andy writes:

Your analysis of Lessig's errors is correct and to-the-point, but limited. The real issue is this: does Lessig oppose the copyright bill because he thinks government can do better, or because he thinks government overstepped limitations on its power? Eagle Forum says the latter, Lessig seems to be pursuing the former. Lessig apparently wants better government, not less government.

Only way he can win is if Eagle Forum persuades Thomas, who pulls in Scalia and Rehnquist, and are joined by some lefties like Stevens or Ginsburg. This case is unwinnable by pleading with the so-called middle, yet that is what Lessig does.

FYI, check out this professor at Texas Tech who teaches key premed programs, and refuses to recommend anyone who won't declare that he believes in evolution.


That is amazing. I had never heard of a science prof who maintained some sort of ideological litmus test for advancing to higher education.
Andy writes:

Roger wrote, "That ruling makes no sense, as there was no vacancy (Torricelli did not become ineligible), and no law could prelude a vacancy anyway."
I disagree. Torricelli has the right to quit the race, and he did. That creates a vacancy, regardless of whether he serves out his existing term.
Roger wrote, "it is not clear that he can withdraw, legally."
Slavery is prohibited. Torricelli can quit, and not be compelled to continue.


Torricelli can quit campaigning. He cannot be forced to actively pursue the office. I agree with Andy on that. But he may not be able to get his name off the ballot. It is possible that he could quit the race and still be a candidate for office.

Does NJ have a mechanism in which a candidate on the ballot can ask that his votes not be counted? Did Torricelli do that?

I don't think so. All he did was to announce his intention to quit campaigning. If his name stays on the ballot and he wins, then he can take office as the elected winner. So there is no vacancy. The Democratic Party announced its intention to replace Torricelli with Lautenberg. But the deadline was past, so the Party had no right to do this under the law. So again, there was no vacancy.

I now looks like Torricelli's name will not be on the ballot, so I guess I was wrong about that. A blatantly political fix by a crooked NJ supreme court has ordered a name substitution past the deadline and without there being a vacancy. I doubt that the US Supreme Court will have the guts to hear the case.

I agree with this:
What the Democrats could do is this: Acknowledge that they are stuck with Torricelli on the ballot. Torricelli promises that if he is elected, he will promptly resign. Then, Governor McGreevey could appoint a Democratic replacement with fewer ethical problems. The replacement could serve until the 2004 general election (although another New Jersey statute gives McGreevey the discretion to call a special election sooner). The Democrats, Torricelli, and McGreevey could even announce in advance who the replacement would be. Voters who trust Torricelli to keep his promise and actually resign, and who want a Democrat to hold the seat, could then vote for Torricelli with a clear conscience.

Friday, October 04, 2002

The US Supreme Court may be tempted to do a repeat of Gore v. Bush, and explain themselves better. It is amazing how much liberal criticism this statement from the majority got when it implied that the decision was for this case only:
The recount process, in its features here described, is inconsistent with the minimum procedures necessary to protect the fundamental right of each voter in the special instance of a statewide recount under the authority of a single state judicial officer. Our consideration is limited to the present circumstances, for the problem of equal protection in election processes generally presents many complexities. The question before the Court is not whether local entities, in the exercise of their expertise, may develop different systems for implementing elections. Instead, we are presented with a situation where a state court with the power to assure uniformity has ordered a statewide recount with minimal procedural safeguards. When a court orders a statewide remedy, there must be at least some assurance that the rudimentary requirements of equal treatment and fundamental fairness are satisfied.

The statement is actually quite reasonable. First, all decisions are limited to the case at hand, according to the cases and controversies clause in the US Constitution. Second, a judicially-ordered (non-statutory) recount should only ever be done under unforeseen circumstances where a proper statutory count is impossible. It is impossible for the Supreme Court to lay down any guidelines for that. If such guidelines were possible, it would be the duty of the legislature to do it. Any rules from the Court would violate the constitutional requirement that the legislature set the rules. Third, the court is ruling narrowly. All the time it happens that a court might have several valid reasons to reject a claim, but it chooses to make the decision hinge on the narrowest reason, so that it does not cause any hasty or ill-considered precedents.

All the Supreme Court can ever do about a judicially-ordered recount is to decide whether the lower court made a compelling case that the recount was necessary and does not violate fundamental laws. No one on the Supreme Court thought that the recount was necessary.

Meanwhile, the wackiest Court opinions came from Souter and Breyer. They agreed that the Florida recount violated equal protection guarantees, so they wanted to order their own recounts! Presumably they had there own non-statutory ideas about how it should have been done.

Then Breyer argued that the Court should not have heard the case, because it could not come to a unanimous decision! He claims to be advocating judicial restraint but judicial restraint would be for the judicially ordered recounts to stop. Breyer really wants a recount that is even more sweeping that what either Gore or the Florida supreme court proposed. His only real complaint is that he couldn't get his fellow judges to go along with it.

Ginsburg concludes, "I cannot agree that the recount adopted by the Florida court, flawed as it may be, would yield a result any less fair or precise than the certification that preceded that recount." She completely misses the point. Any change to the vote counting rules is inherently unfair. There are dozens of counting procedures that might seem fair, and which the legislature could have reasonably chosen. By Ginsburg's logic, the Florida court could just keep ordering recounts until Gore ends up on top.

The main gripe from Stevens is the "lack of confidence in the impartiality and capacity of the state judges who would make the critical decisions if the vote count were to proceed." Of course we don't have confidence in letting judges rewrite election rules. Nobody ever has. That is why the Constitution makes it the duty of the legislatures to write the election laws.

It appears that the US Supreme Court is due for a lot more criticism. If it refuses to hear the Torricelli case, then it will accused of acting only to help Bush, but not to others who are similarly cheated. If it uploads the NJ ballot statute and puts Torricelli back on the ballot, it will be accused of being partisan to help Republicans again. If it rules the NJ court can order an an election be held contrary to the statutes, then it will be inconsistent with Gove v. Bush.

The election rules have to be set by the legislature, not the courts:
US Constitution, Article I, Section. 4. (1) The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators.

The NJ legislature set a 51-day deadline. Any court attempt to change that is unconstitutional. We'll soon see if the US Supreme Court has the guts to stand up for constitutional requirements.

Thursday, October 03, 2002

Andy sends this article about the new Miss America having conservative views that are not being reported.
Some lawmakers are showing some interest in limiting the recent expansion of copyright law. Here is some discussion of Lofgren's bill.
Update: Boucher introduced his bill.

Wednesday, October 02, 2002

Apparently the fix was in at the NJ supreme court. No one could figure out why Torricelli would pull out of the Senate race since it was too late under the law to put a replacement on the ballot. The NJ court just said yes. This is more evidence that the Democrats are election crooks. The Republicans should immediately appeal to federal court, because the integrity of a federal election is at stake.

I expect that Dershowitz will soon make a bunch of dishonest rationalizations about how the Democrats should be able to rig the NJ ballot in their favor.

Here is the NY Times story, and the court decision. The main part is:
And the Court having determined that N.J.S.A. 19:13-20 does not preclude the possibility of a vacancy occurring within fifty-one days of the general election; And the Court having concluded that the equitable relief sought herein is not inconsistent with the precedent of this Court and the terms of the statute and that the Court should invoke its equitable powers in favor of a full and fair ballot choice for the voters of New Jersey;


There is no vacancy. There is only a party that wants to make a change. Changing the election rules after an election has begun because one side wants to make a tactical response to some bad polling data is not "full and fair".
Here is another example of how lawyers think differently. Alan Dershowitz was teaching a Harvard class today on legal ethics, and was discussing what to do if your client lies on the stand. Yeah, this is a little bit like Tony Soprano teaching a course on gangster ethics. Dershowitz is not exactly known for ethical behavior. According to one of his students, Dershowitz's solution is for the lawyer to first tell the judge a lie in order to disrupt the trial!
WSJ says:
"The Arab-American community has reacted angrily to the news, saying people will be targeted on the basis of their race and religion," the BBC reports. The "news" in question is the Immigration and Naturalization Service's plan to subject visitors from such countries as Iraq, Libya, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Sudan and Yemen to special scrutiny, including fingerprinting.
We'll tell the Arab-American community what: When government-appointed imams in these countries stop delivering sermons calling for the deaths of Jews and Christians, we'll start listening to Arab-Americans' complaints about targeting foreign nationals "on the basis of their race and religion."

John sends this story about Congress allocating a measly $10,000 to encourage amateur astronomers to be on the lookout for asteroids and comets that are about to hit the Earth and wipe out human civilization. This must be the smallest dollar amount in the budget, and the biggest worse-case scenario that Congress contemplates.

Tuesday, October 01, 2002

A new Danish study says that it is bad to scold a child [CNN and Reuters]:
"You can't say that it's better to scold your child than to beat it. When you punish a child you give it the feeling that it isn't worth anything," Sigsgaard told Reuters. ... According to the United Nation's child rights convention, children have the right to protection from physical and psychological violence and abuse.
Spanking is already illegal in Denmark. Is scolding next? Here is some analysis.
TV news shows continue to describe wacky scenarios for NJ election problems, and they are endorsed by supposed experts. One says that Torricelli can resign, and the NJ governor can appoint a replacement until Nov. 2003. Another says that the replacement would automatically get to be on the ballot next month because he will be the incumbent. Another says an incumbent Congressman can take Torricelli's place, and someone else can replace that Congressman's name on the ballot. Another says that a special election will have to be held.

None of these make any sense at all. If Torricelli resigns, then that creates a very short term vacancy that the governor can fill. But the Nov. ballot will have to have Torricelli's name on it. He was the choice of the Democratic primary, and that cannot be changed now. NJ law and elementary fairness don't allow any other alternative. Any election has to be carried out under pre-existing rules, or it is a crooked election. No action by the governor can make a 6-year US Senate term last any longer than 6 years. Ballots have already been printed. Some overseas soldiers may have already voted. There is no way that the Democrats can retain the NJ US Senate seat unless Torricelli changes his mind and somehow wins the election.

George writes: "The fix is in. The Democrats would not have had Torricelli quit unless they were sure to get someone else on the ballot instead. The NJ Supreme Court has already agreed to hear the case. That court is an appellate court. The facts can only come from a lower court. A deal must have already been struck with crooks on the NJ Supreme Court."

Maybe the US Supreme Court will have to straighten out a crooked Democratic state supreme court again. Here is a wacky theory from CounterSpin, claiming that the Democrats can just call off the election if they are losing. The idea is that if Torricelli resigns less than 30 days before an election, then the governor can appoint a temporary replacement, and it is too close before the election for the election to determine the replacement.

I looked at the law, and the theory doesn't make any sense. The governor can fill a vacancy, but he cannot call off an election for a Senator to serve in the next term. The election will proceed as scheduled, and the winner will immediately take office. The law says:


If a vacancy shall happen in the representation of this state in the United States senate, it shall be filled at the general election next succeeding the happening thereof, unless such vacancy shall happen within thirty days next preceding such election, in which case it shall be filled by election at the second succeeding general election [or a special election].


If Torricelli resigns, then the vacancy is only in the current term. The election will take place to fill the next term, starting in Jan. 2003. If Torricelli resigns now, then the Nov. 2002 election will fill his vacancy as well as decide who serves the next term. If he resigns next week, then I guess the Nov. 2002 election will not fill the vacancy, but it will still determine who serves the next term.

If the CounterSpin theory were correct, it would be possible for an incumbent Senator, who wasn't even running for re-election, to sabotage an election just by resigning. The election is necessary for the new term, whether there is a vacancy in the old term or not. I don't see any way to read the law, except to say that Forrester and Torricelli will both be on the NJ ballot next month.
Matt Drudge caught Barbra Streisand arguing against war with a bogus Shakespeare quote. She fell for net hoax. The quote is not even in iambic pentameter verse. I wonder if her research on Iraq was any better.
Update: NY Times summarizes the dispute.
John sends this column on smarts. It says that public perception is the smartest Supreme Court judges are Scalia, Breyer and Souter, and the dumbest are Kennedy, O'Connor, and Thomas. The author's friends with inside knowledge say that Rehnquist and Thomas are the smartest.

This shows how public perception of intelligence can be wrong, and stay wrong for many years. Thomas has written many brilliant opinions with extremely compelling arguments. Hardly anyone attacks him on the substance of what he writes, because they cannot rebut it. People say he is stupid, and yet the people who say that show no sign of even having read any of his opinions. Meanwhile, Ginsburg and Souter have hardly written any noteworthy opinions. I say that Thomas is much smarter than Ginsburg or Souter.

Monday, September 30, 2002

Here is a company that uses DNA to figure out your ancestry, as reported in the NY Times. Some politically correct scientists are uneasy about this, because they pretend that genetics has proved that there is no such thing as race. One says, "This test really jumps the gun in reifying groups that don't have scientific support". Not only does DNA analysis find racial markers, $160 and a swab from your inside cheek will quantify your racial background.
If we goto war against Iraq, I'd like understand the precise reasons. I've heard:


  • Iraq might make a terrorist attack on the US.
  • Iraq supports suicide bombers in Israel.
  • After 9/11, we still need to kick some moslem/arab butt.
  • Iraq has not cooperated with UN weapons inspections.
  • US is the world's imperial power, and has to keep outlaw states in check.
  • Iraq has weapons of mass destruction that will destabilize the Mideast.
  • Hussein's attitude only proves we should have finished the job in 1991.

Which is it?
John writes:

If you want to know how Torricelli went from a sure winner to a sure loser in the last two weeks, watch this hour-long investigative report shown on a major New York TV station last week, Sep. 26: Go to FeedRoom, click on Parts 1, 2, and 3.

David Chang is a compelling, believable witness against the Torch. Like the "Final Days" scandals, the Torricelli case was one more Mary Jo Whitewash.

Since the statutory deadline has passed to take Torricelli's name off the ballot and substitute another candidate, the Democrats have filed an emergency petition asking the NJ Supreme Court to disregard the law and allow another Democrat on the ballot.


It is hard to imagine a more groundless request to bypass a routine election law. It might be one thing if he had some sudden illness, or got appointed to some more important job, or some other unforeseen emergency. (The corruption charges were not new.) But Torricelli's decision was based on nothing new but:

  1. a drop in the polls
  2. panic about the party losing the seat
  3. the Republican had based his campaign on Torricelli's record

It is hard to imagine worse reasons. The whole point of having a frozen ballot is so that the candidates have time to educate the voters on the differences between the candidates. If a party can bail out of a loser with a last-minute switcheroo, then it defeats the whole point of having debates between candidates.

I just don't believe the NJ Supreme Court is going to do it. It sounds too much like Florida two years ago, when the Florida supreme court tried to tamper with a federal election by changing the rules after-the-fact for no good reason except to favor the Democrats.

Andy writes:

The Torricelli flame-out is spectatular. But the fix is probably in. New Jersey Supreme Court is probably more liberal than Florida's. Perhaps conservatives should focus more on cleaning up state courts.
McBride has closed with 4 points of Jeb Bush in Florida. Jeb, recently viewed as a shoo-in, may well lose. What conservative accomplishment can he run on? He embraced Big Government with the Model State Emergency Health Powers Act and probably in many other ways also. His fix for education has been vouchers rather than, say, conservative curriculum changes and tough conservative administrators. His daughter seems to have a serious drug problem, something we now hold parents accountable for in housing projects. GWB doesn't seem to give him any boost.
And, of course, Jeb erred in thinking politics was symmetric and therefore that he could influence the Democratic primary (as Davis did to Republicans in California). Bush's intrusion probably gave McBride the key primary win.
Too bad, because Jeb is a much more effective politician than GWB. GWB really should have been held more accountable for losing the US Senate than he was.


John sends this analysis that clearly explains why it is impossible under the law to replace Torricelli on the NJ ballot. It is amazing how the Democrats try to use the courts to manipulate a federal election so soon after they tried and failed in 2000.

I listened to this story on NPR, and the left-wing bias was more than usual. It told the whole Torricelli story from the viewpoint of how the Democrats are trying to retain control of the Senate. In the end, it said that it was up to the NJ Gov. and supreme court to decide who goes on the ballot, and that the Republican deserved to face another candidate because he campaigned so hard against Torricelli.

Update: Actually, the news segment on the web site now is much better than what was broadcast on All Things Considered yesterday. Somebody must have convinced NPR that it was just broadcasting Democratic Party propaganda. But it still quotes political analysts as saying that Torricelli dropping out makes it much easier for Democrats to keep control of the Senate seat, because another strong candidate will replace him on the ballot. As I understand the NJ law, the Democratic Party can only put Torricelli's name on the ballot. Electing any other Democrat would require telling voters to ignore Torricelli's name and write in someone else. Not likely.
Business Week has a story about the upcoming US Supreme Court oral arguments on the Mickey Mouse copyright extension law that extended copyright terms to life plus 70 years. It says:


That issue is whether Congress has the right to extend copyright law if the change does not promote the "progress of science and useful arts" as stated in Article 1, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution. ...

The case is a crucible, not only for the CTEA, but for all future copyright laws. And Lessig's strategy is both bold and fraught with risk. "What the Supreme Court must answer is whether the intention of copyright is to protect economic value or to promote science and the arts," says Peter Jaszi, a professor of copyright law at American University Law School. If the court overturns the law, it could call into question a host of other unpopular laws, especially the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. But if the law is upheld, it will be a huge setback for digital-rights activists.

John sends this AP story as another example of how a confidential settlement agreement might be contrary to the public interest. WTC 9/11 lawsuits have cornered all the expert data and opinion on what happened, but the courts may prevent it from ever seeing the light of day. See also NY Times story.

Sunday, September 29, 2002

Andy says that various professional organizations are petitioning the US Supreme Court to let them write model laws, copyright them, lobby for their passage, and charge money for anyone who wants a copy. The case is Veeck v. SBCCI. Veeck put some building codes for his area in Texas on the internet, and got sued for copyright infringement. He lost in district court, lost 2-1 on his first appeal, and won 6-4 on his second.

The petition by the copyright lobby is superficially persuasive, but it rests on bad facts, bad economics, bad policy, and bad law. As Andy points out, there are no facts to support the argument, except self-serving claims by SBCCI management that they'd lose money-making opportunities. The bad economics is to think that letting private companies sell legal codes is an efficient way to development good legal codes. The bad policy is to let private, unaccountable, revenue-driven businessmen gain a monopoly on the text of the law. (At one point it brags that one private copyrighted code "has been adopted in all fifty states, Puerto Rico, Guam, and by the federal government.") The bad law is to think that any of this is a basis for reverse an 1888 Sup. Ct. precedent.

Here is one of its silly points:

As a practical matter, throughout our history, even the non-copyrighted portions of statutes and judicial decisions have been available only to lawyers, law schools, and libraries willing to pay the commercial publishers such as West Publishing who actually print and distribute the text of statutes and opinions.


Andy is writing an amicus brief for the case. Because of the similarity to the case involving the AMA/Medicare CPT codes for medical services, I have posted a copy of the medical codes here. As you can see, they are just a bunch of 5-digit numbers that are used to describe billable services, such as "chest x-ray".

Saturday, September 28, 2002

John sends this Mercury News story about the H1-B visa scam. Silicon Valley lobbied for a special immigration law allowing 100s of thousands of engineers from India and China to come to the US on the theory that there were no Americans to fill the jobs. Actually, there were plenty of Americans, but the companies preferred to hire the lower-wage and less mobile foreigners. Now we see the proof, as 10s of thousands of American engineers have been laid off in Silicon Valley, and the H1-B workers still have jobs.
John sends this story about Critical Mass, a monthly bicycle ride in San Francisco. Yesterday's was unusually large, and had thousands of riders. A lot of motorists complain because they don't think that bicycles belong on the road. A lot of people think that the ride is some sort of protest, and that the cyclists are deliberately blocking traffic in order to make some sort of political point. But it is really not. They are just bicycle enthusiasts who want to ride on the streets safely and with other bicyclists. Riding a bicycle on streets full of other cyclists is a lot more enjoyable that trying to ride on streets dominated by motorists.

Friday, September 27, 2002

Idiotic article of the day. Slate's Dahlia Lithwick has a rant against Ashcroft, and his position that the Second Amendment protects individual gun rights. It is thoroughly debunked on by InstaPundit and Volokh. Both of them say that Lithwick has written other good stuff, but I don't know why -- it seems to me that she botches the law every time and these guys have to straighten her out.

The whole Lithwick article has the erroneous premise that Ashcroft thinks that US v. Miller (1939), the leading Supreme Court case on the issue, was wrongly decided. He does not. His position is very similar to that of the recent US v. Emerson case, which completely accepted US v. Miller as good law. Ashcroft is merely accepting what most legal scholars have said for the last 200 years. It is not a radical position. Then she is puzzled as to why Ashcroft has not acted to overturn gun laws. She doesn't want him to overturn any gun laws, but she is puzzled anyway. Then she answers her own question by noting that Ashcroft testified in his confirmation hearings that he is willing to abide by gun control laws even if he personally disagrees with them. Finally, she thinks that this is proof that Ashcroft lied during the hearings, and should have been given a polygraph.

Lithwick's level of idiocy is only found among lawyers. Ashcroft is not seeking to reverse laws because his job as Attorney General is to uphold laws. He explained that rather well during his confirmation hearings, and spoke the obvious truth. Leftists are always trying to accuse right-wings of hypocrisy. When they cannot find any, they invent it. When someone like Ashcroft does what he is supposed to do, and stands firmly on his principles, it drives them bonkers.

Her mindless antagonism towards Ashcroft is rooted in politics, of course. She says, "what's to stop him from instituting a DOJ policy barring minors from access to abortions, because he believes that Roe v. Wade was also wrongly decided?". Guess what -- everybody thinks that Roe v. Wade was wrongly decided. Even left-wing pro-abortion law profs do not defend the logic of Roe v. Wade and wish that abortion could have been legalized by some other means. But as Ashcroft has also explained, it is also settled law and the Attorney General has to accept it.

Here is a NY Times attack on Bush's latest controversial judge nominee because he thinks that Roe v. Wade was wrongly decided. I'd like to cross-examine the political hit men who pretend that Roe v. Wade was correctly decided, and make them defend the reasoning. The vast majority of the American public has misunderstandings about just what Roe v. Wade decided.
John sends this article about the upcoming Supreme Court oral arguments over copyright extension. Cringely supports civil disobedience against extreme copyright laws like the DMCA. More info at Eldred v. Ashcroft. It would be nice if the Supreme Court said that there are some limits to what copyright law can do, because Congress is planning some even worse copyright laws. Here is a new LA Times article about Lessig and the copyright fight. Again, Lessig tries to disassociate himself from his conservative past, but he says things like ''Everything that Washington proposes gets worse than the thing they did before''. I think that Lessig really wants to be a conservative, but it is socially unacceptable among law profs for him to admit it.